Free radical scavenging and inhibition of lipid peroxidation by beta-blockers and by agents that interfere with calcium metabolism. A physiologically-significant process?

It has been proposed that beta-blockers and agents affecting Ca2+ metabolism might exert cardioprotective actions because of their ability to act as antioxidants in vivo. The feasibility of this proposal was tested by examining the reaction of a series of such compounds with various oxygen-derived species. None of the compounds tested was sufficiently reactive with superoxide radical, hydrogen peroxide or hypochlorous acid for scavenging of these species to be feasible in vivo at the drug concentrations present in patients given the usual therapeutic doses. All the drugs tested were powerful scavengers of hydroxyl radical except for flunarizine, which stimulated iron ion-dependent hydroxyl radical generation from hydrogen peroxide. However, none of the drugs significantly inhibited production of hydroxyl radicals in this system. Propranolol, verapamil and flunarizine had significant inhibitory effects on the peroxidation of rat liver microsomes in the presence of iron ions and ascorbic acid. All three compounds exerted weaker inhibitory effects on peroxidation of arachidonic acid caused by a mixture of myoglobin and H2O2: pindolol stimulated peroxidation in this system. It is concluded that the ability of beta-blockers and "Ca(2+)-blockers" to inhibit lipid peroxidation varies with the lipid substrate used and the mechanism by which peroxidation is induced. We conclude that suggestions that beta-blockers and "Ca(2+)-blockers" exert antioxidant effects in vivo are not well founded, although there is a possibility that verapamil and propranolol might have some inhibitory effects against peroxidation if they accumulate in membranes to a sufficiently-high concentration in vivo. We could not confirm the reported ability of propranolol to inhibit the enzyme xanthine oxidase.