Katz William F, Bharadwaj Sneha V, Stettler Monica P
Callier Center for Communication Disorders, University of Texas at Dallas, 75235, USA.
J Speech Lang Hear Res. 2006 Jun;49(3):645-59. doi: 10.1044/1092-4388(2006/047).
This study examined whether the intraoral transducers used in electromagnetic articulography (EMA) interfere with speech and whether there is an added risk of interference when EMA systems are used to study individuals with aphasia and apraxia.
Ten adult talkers (5 individuals with aphasia/apraxia, 5 controls) produced 12 American English vowels in /hVd/ words, the fricative-vowel (FV) words (/si/, /su/, /ei/, /eu/), and the sentence She had your dark suit in greasy wash water all year, in EMA sensors-on and sensors-off conditions. Segmental durations, vowel formant frequencies, and fricative spectral moments were measured to address possible acoustic effects of sensor placement. A perceptual experiment examined whether FV words produced in the sensors-on condition were less identifiable than those produced in the sensors-off condition.
EMA sensors caused no consistent acoustic effects across all talkers, although significant within-subject effects were noted for a small subset of the talkers. The perceptual results revealed some instances of sensor-related intelligibility loss for FV words produced by individuals with aphasia and apraxia.
The findings support previous suggestions that acoustic screening procedures be used to protect articulatory experiments from those individuals who may show consistent effects of having devices placed on intraoral structures. The findings further suggest that studies of fricatives produced by individuals with aphasia and apraxia may require additional safeguards to ensure that results are not adversely affected by intraoral sensor interference.
本研究旨在探讨电磁关节造影(EMA)中使用的口腔内传感器是否会干扰言语,以及当EMA系统用于研究失语症和失用症患者时是否存在额外的干扰风险。
10名成年说话者(5名失语症/失用症患者,5名对照者)在EMA传感器开启和关闭的情况下,在/hVd/单词、擦音-元音(FV)单词(/si/、/su/、/ei/、/eu/)以及句子“她一整年都把你深色的套装泡在油腻的洗涤水里”中发出12个美式英语元音。测量了音段时长、元音共振峰频率和擦音频谱矩,以探讨传感器放置可能产生的声学影响。一项感知实验检验了在传感器开启条件下发出的FV单词是否比在传感器关闭条件下发出的单词更难识别。
尽管在一小部分说话者中观察到了显著的个体内效应,但EMA传感器在所有说话者中并未产生一致的声学影响。感知结果显示,失语症和失用症患者发出的FV单词存在一些与传感器相关的可懂度损失情况。
这些发现支持了之前的建议,即应采用声学筛查程序,以保护发音实验不受那些可能因在口腔内结构上放置设备而产生一致影响的个体的干扰。这些发现还进一步表明,对失语症和失用症患者发出的擦音进行研究可能需要额外的保障措施,以确保结果不会受到口腔内传感器干扰的不利影响。