Cooke Richard, Peel Elizabeth, Shaw Rachel L, Senior Carl
School of Life and Health Sciences, Aston University, UK.
Int J Psychophysiol. 2007 Feb;63(2):152-8. doi: 10.1016/j.ijpsycho.2006.03.014. Epub 2006 Jun 27.
The aim of this study was to investigate participants' experiences of taking part in research conducted using fMRI or MEG procedures. Forty-four participants completed a questionnaire after taking part in either fMRI or MEG experiments; the questionnaire asked about experiences of and attitudes toward fMRI/MEG. Ten follow-up interviews were conducted to enable an in-depth analysis of these attitudes and experiences. The findings were generally positive: all participants thought fMRI and MEG were safe procedures, 93% would recommend participating in neuroimaging research to their friends and family, and participants were positive about participating in future neuroimaging research. However, some negative issues were identified. Some participants reported feeling nervous prior to scanning procedures, several participants reported side-effects after taking part, a number of participants were upset at being in a confined space and some participants did not feel confident about exiting the scanner in an emergency. Several recommendations for researchers are made, including a virtual tour of the scanning equipment during the consenting process in order to better prepare potential participants for the scanning experience and to minimize the potential psychological discomfort sometimes experienced in neuroimaging research.
本研究的目的是调查参与者参与使用功能磁共振成像(fMRI)或脑磁图(MEG)程序进行的研究的体验。44名参与者在参与fMRI或MEG实验后完成了一份问卷;该问卷询问了对fMRI/MEG的体验和态度。进行了10次后续访谈,以便对这些态度和体验进行深入分析。结果总体上是积极的:所有参与者都认为fMRI和MEG是安全的程序,93%的人会向朋友和家人推荐参与神经成像研究,并且参与者对参与未来的神经成像研究持积极态度。然而,也发现了一些负面问题。一些参与者报告在扫描程序前感到紧张,几名参与者报告参与后有副作用,一些参与者对身处密闭空间感到不安,还有一些参与者对在紧急情况下退出扫描仪没有信心。针对研究人员提出了一些建议,包括在同意过程中对扫描设备进行虚拟参观,以便更好地让潜在参与者为扫描体验做好准备,并尽量减少神经成像研究中有时会出现的潜在心理不适。