Maggioni Cristina, Margola Davide, Filippi Francesca
2 Clinica Ostetrico-Ginecologica, University of Milan, Italy.
J Psychosom Obstet Gynaecol. 2006 Jun;27(2):81-90. doi: 10.1080/01674820600712875.
The aim of the study was to evaluate the incidence of chronic post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) after childbirth in relation to pre-partum variables (personality characteristics, anamnestic risk factors) and intra-partum obstetrical and neonatal variables. Since expectations before an event could modify the perceptions, reactions, and satisfaction afterward, the representations of the idealized delivery were carefully analyzed. Moreover, the real and desired help perception from physicians and family members were separately considered during pregnancy and after delivery in relation to PTSD.
The study was carried out submitting a questionnaire to pregnant women twice: firstly when women were in their 38 << 42 gestational week (Time 1) and secondly after 3-6 months from childbirth (Time 2). 93 women were recruited at a University City Hospital in Milan, Italy. PTSD subscales, depression, and anxiety levels were also assessed.
2.4% of women had a complete PTSD, while 32.1% of them resulted in having one or two positive subscales of symptoms: 15.5% (N = 13) had a positive intrusion subscale, 25.0% (N = 21) had a positive arousal subscale, while only 3.6% (N = 3) had a positive avoidance subscale. Pre-delivery depression influences PTSD, but only for the intrusion subscale. Pre-delivery physical risk factors are linked to PTSD on the avoidance subscale. At Time 2 depression and PTSD are often present simultaneously. Given the high percentage of healthy newborns, intra-partum obstetrical variables do not seem to influence PTSD. High trait anxiety distinctively coexists with a specific expected delivery and a 'deception' in desired and real support from professionals.
Childbirth is a risk condition for PTSD, depression during pregnancy influences the intrusion subscale, while having physical problems influences the arousal subscale. Expectations and support are modulated by the anxiety levels and they are not directly related to chronic PTSD.
本研究旨在评估产后慢性创伤后应激障碍(PTSD)的发生率与产前变量(人格特征、既往危险因素)以及产时产科和新生儿变量之间的关系。由于事件发生前的期望可能会改变之后的认知、反应和满意度,因此对理想化分娩的表现进行了仔细分析。此外,还分别考虑了孕期和产后医生及家庭成员实际给予的帮助和期望得到的帮助与创伤后应激障碍的关系。
本研究通过向孕妇两次发放问卷进行:第一次是在妊娠38至42周时(时间1),第二次是在产后3至6个月(时间2)。在意大利米兰的一家大学城市医院招募了93名女性。还评估了创伤后应激障碍分量表、抑郁和焦虑水平。
2.4%的女性患有完全性创伤后应激障碍,而其中32.1%的女性有一或两个症状分量表呈阳性:15.5%(N = 13)的侵入分量表呈阳性,25.0%(N = 21)的觉醒分量表呈阳性,而只有3.6%(N = 3)的回避分量表呈阳性。产前抑郁会影响创伤后应激障碍,但仅对侵入分量表有影响。产前身体危险因素与回避分量表上的创伤后应激障碍有关。在时间2时,抑郁和创伤后应激障碍常常同时出现。鉴于健康新生儿的比例较高,产时产科变量似乎不会影响创伤后应激障碍。高特质焦虑与特定的预期分娩以及专业人员给予的实际支持和期望得到的支持之间存在明显的“落差”。
分娩是创伤后应激障碍的一个风险因素,孕期抑郁会影响侵入分量表,而身体问题会影响觉醒分量表。期望和支持受焦虑水平的调节,它们与慢性创伤后应激障碍没有直接关系。