Hamlat Abderrahmane, Saikali Stephan, Chaperon Jacques, Carsin-Nicol Beatrice, Calve Michéle Le, Lesimple Thierry, Ben-hassel Mohamed, Guegan Yvon
Department of Neurosurgery, CHU Pontchaillou, Rennes, France.
J Neurooncol. 2006 Sep;79(2):159-68. doi: 10.1007/s11060-005-9026-8.
Histological, clinical and radiological features, and molecular genetic analysis are among the factors that have been considered in defining the prognosis of oligodendrogliomas (OD), but they have yielded conflicting results. The purpose of this study was to test out a scoring scale based on clinical, radiological, pathological and molecular features.
To identify factors with prognostic significance, we analyzed 87 treated patients with a histological diagnosis of OD. Of the parameters analyzed, age, onset, clinical status, radiological enhancement, histological necrosis, mitosis and chromosomal anomalies emerged as significant prognosis factors using univariate analysis. Multivariate analysis revealed age and chromosomal anomalies as independent factors of survival.
The factors with a significant prognostic value were combined to determine which grouping factors best predict outcome. The proposed score is a pure number resulting from a combination of: 2 major factors: age and chromosomal anomalies (scored 3-0); 5 minor factors: onset, clinical examination, necrosis, mitoses (scored 1-0), and radiological enhancement (scored 2-0). According to our scale, 10 survival curves were produced for overall survival. Recursive partitioning of patients with the nearest score and outcome produced four groups with a significant difference in survival (p=10(-5)). The power of both the scale and the partitioned groups for predicting outcome was more accurate than the WHO and St Anne grading systems, and the molecular sub-classification.
Our scale is a plausible way of classifying patients harboring intracranial OD according to expected survival.
组织学、临床和放射学特征以及分子遗传学分析是在确定少突胶质细胞瘤(OD)预后时所考虑的因素,但它们得出了相互矛盾的结果。本研究的目的是测试一种基于临床、放射学、病理学和分子特征的评分量表。
为了确定具有预后意义的因素,我们分析了87例经组织学诊断为OD的接受治疗的患者。在分析的参数中,单因素分析显示年龄、发病情况、临床状态、放射学增强、组织学坏死、有丝分裂和染色体异常是显著的预后因素。多因素分析显示年龄和染色体异常是生存的独立因素。
将具有显著预后价值的因素结合起来,以确定哪些分组因素最能预测结果。所提出的评分是一个由以下因素组合而成的纯数字:2个主要因素:年龄和染色体异常(评分3 - 0);5个次要因素:发病情况、临床检查、坏死、有丝分裂(评分1 - 0)和放射学增强(评分2 - 0)。根据我们的量表,生成了10条总生存曲线。对得分和结果最接近的患者进行递归分割,产生了四组生存有显著差异的患者(p = 10^(-5))。该量表和分割组预测结果的能力比世界卫生组织(WHO)和圣安妮分级系统以及分子亚分类更准确。
我们的量表是根据预期生存情况对颅内OD患者进行分类的一种合理方法。