Deschenes Michael R, Hillard Mackenzi N, Wilson Jill A, Dubina Meghan I, Eason Margaret K
Department of Kinesiology, The College of William and Mary, Williamsburg, VA 23187-8795, USA.
Med Sci Sports Exerc. 2006 Jul;38(7):1304-10. doi: 10.1249/01.mss.0000227316.93351.56.
This investigation was conducted to compare the physiological responses of men and women, both during and following an exercise bout at the same relative submaximal intensity.
Ten untrained men (20.7+/-0.5 yr, 178.4+/-2.3 cm, 79.6+/-4.8 kg; mean+/-SE) and 10 untrained women (20.3+/-0.3 yr, 163.8+/-2.2 cm, 59.5+/-2.1 kg) cycled for 30 min at 60-65% of their predetermined peak oxygen uptake. Physiological variables were measured before exercise, at 15 and 30 min of exercise, and at 5 and 15 min postexercise. For each variable of interest, a two-way repeated-measures of analysis was used to assess the main effects of gender and time, along with potential interactive effects.
Our data revealed that for many variables including HR, relative HR (% peak value), mean arterial pressure, and rectal temperature, men and women responded similarly both during exercise and throughout the recovery period. In contrast, significant (P<or=0.05) gender-related differences were noted for RER, plasma lactate, systolic blood pressure, and plasma volume shifts. In each of those variables, values displayed by men during exercise were significantly greater than those observed among women. However, with the exception of plasma lactate, those gender-related differences did not persist into recovery.
During exercise of the same relative submaximal intensity, some physiological parameters responded likewise in young men and young women, whereas others did not. Among those variables that demonstrated significant gender-related differences, all but one (plasma lactate) were obscured within 5 min of postexercise recovery.
本研究旨在比较男性和女性在相同相对亚最大强度运动期间及运动后的生理反应。
10名未经训练的男性(20.7±0.5岁,身高178.4±2.3厘米,体重79.6±4.8千克;平均值±标准误)和10名未经训练的女性(20.3±0.3岁,身高163.8±2.2厘米,体重59.5±2.1千克)以其预定峰值摄氧量的60 - 65%进行30分钟的骑行。在运动前、运动15分钟和30分钟时以及运动后5分钟和15分钟测量生理变量。对于每个感兴趣的变量,采用双向重复测量分析来评估性别和时间的主要影响以及潜在的交互作用。
我们的数据显示,对于包括心率、相对心率(%峰值)、平均动脉压和直肠温度在内的许多变量,男性和女性在运动期间及整个恢复期间的反应相似。相比之下,在呼吸交换率、血浆乳酸、收缩压和血浆容量变化方面存在显著(P≤0.05)的性别差异。在这些变量中的每一个中,男性在运动期间显示的值显著高于女性观察到的值。然而,除了血浆乳酸外,这些性别差异在恢复过程中并未持续存在。
在相同相对亚最大强度的运动中,一些生理参数在年轻男性和年轻女性中的反应相同,而另一些则不同。在那些显示出显著性别差异的变量中,除了一个(血浆乳酸)外,所有差异在运动后恢复5分钟内都消失了。