Richard Stephanie A, Zavaleta Nelly, Caulfield Laura E, Black Robert E, Witzig Richard S, Shankar Anuraj H
Center for Human Nutrition, and Department of International Health, The Johns Hopkins University Bloomberg School of Public Health, Baltimore, Maryland 21205, USA.
Am J Trop Med Hyg. 2006 Jul;75(1):126-32. doi: 10.4269/ajtmh.2006.75.1.0750126.
Iron and zinc deficiencies are common in developing countries and supplementation is one way of reversing these deficiencies. The objective of this randomized, placebo-controlled clinical trial was to identify the effect of daily supplementation with iron, zinc, and iron plus zinc on the morbidity experience of 855 children 0.5-15 years of age in Peru. Single nutrient supplementation with zinc reduced diarrhea morbidity by 23% in all children. In older children (more than five years of age), iron supplementation increased morbidity due to Plasmodium vivax and diarrhea. In younger children, iron combined with zinc provided protection against P. vivax malaria, but also interfered with some of the diarrhea protection associated with zinc supplementation. No statistically significant effect was observed of either supplement on incidence of respiratory infection or anthropometric indices. Iron and zinc deficiencies should be remedied, and combined supplementation may be a good option, particularly in younger children in P. vivax malaria-endemic areas, although local endemicity and species-specific prevalence should be considered carefully when designing any supplementation program involving iron in a malaria-endemic area.
铁缺乏和锌缺乏在发展中国家很常见,补充是扭转这些缺乏状况的一种方法。这项随机、安慰剂对照临床试验的目的是确定每日补充铁、锌以及铁加锌对秘鲁855名0.5至15岁儿童发病情况的影响。单独补充锌可使所有儿童的腹泻发病率降低23%。在大龄儿童(五岁以上)中,补充铁会增加间日疟原虫感染和腹泻导致的发病率。在低龄儿童中,铁与锌联合补充可预防间日疟,但也会干扰一些与锌补充相关的腹泻预防效果。未观察到任何一种补充剂对呼吸道感染发病率或人体测量指标有统计学显著影响。铁缺乏和锌缺乏应得到纠正,联合补充可能是一个不错的选择,特别是在间日疟流行地区的低龄儿童中,不过在设计任何涉及在疟疾流行地区补充铁的补充计划时,应仔细考虑当地的流行情况和特定物种的患病率。