Nagaratnam Nages, Keen Ross, Gayagay George
Blacktown-Mt Druitt Health, North Rocks, Australia.
Am J Alzheimers Dis Other Demen. 2006 Jun-Jul;21(3):164-8. doi: 10.1177/1533317506288987.
The purpose of this retrospective study of 116 dementia patients with and without accusatory behavior was to determine its frequency and evaluate its relationship to individual characteristics, behavioral and psychological symptoms, and certain dementia-related domains, namely, cognitive impairment, stage of disease, language difficulties, and functional disability. Little more than one third (38%) of the patients studied had accusatory behavior. The average age of the patients with accusatory behavior was 74 years, and the male to female ratio was 2.6:1. Accusatory behavior was more prevalent in the higher stages of dementia by 2- to 3-fold and was positively associated with hallucinations. Three patients with accusatory behavior had delusions of infidelity. There were no significant associations between accusatory behavior and other categories studied. This study raises a caveat of issues and, more important, whether the different themes relating to accusatory behaviors are true delusions, persecutory ideation, misidentification, nondelusional suspiciousness, or other. It is suggested that it would be more useful to relate them as symptoms.
这项针对116名有或无指责行为的痴呆症患者的回顾性研究,旨在确定指责行为的发生率,并评估其与个体特征、行为和心理症状以及某些与痴呆症相关的领域(即认知障碍、疾病阶段、语言困难和功能残疾)之间的关系。研究的患者中略多于三分之一(38%)有指责行为。有指责行为的患者平均年龄为74岁,男女比例为2.6:1。指责行为在痴呆症较高阶段的发生率高出2至3倍,且与幻觉呈正相关。三名有指责行为的患者存在不忠妄想。指责行为与所研究的其他类别之间无显著关联。这项研究提出了一系列问题,更重要的是,与指责行为相关的不同主题究竟是真正的妄想、被害妄想、身份识别错误、非妄想性猜疑还是其他情况。建议将它们作为症状来关联可能更有用。