Lacoste Sandrine, Castonguay André, Drouin Régen
Service of Genetics, Department of Paediatrics, Faculty of Medicine and Health Sciences, University of Sherbrooke, 3001, 12th Avenue North, Sherbrooke, Que., Canada J1H 5N4.
Mutat Res. 2006 Aug 30;600(1-2):138-49. doi: 10.1016/j.mrfmmm.2006.04.005. Epub 2006 Aug 17.
4-(Methylnitrosamino)-1-(3-pyridyl)-1-butanone (NNK) is the most lung-specific of the carcinogens present in tobacco smoke. Its bioactivation in cells leads to a small amount of methylation or pyridyloxobutylation DNA damage. Considering its great sensitivity, the comet assay seems a technique of choice to investigate NNK-related damage. Several strategies were used to impart some specificity to the assay: (1) using analogs that produce a limited variety of DNA lesions, as they mimic either the methylation or the pyridyloxobutylation pathway; (2) using cells with different bioactivation abilities; (3) using alkali conversion and/or enzymes specific for cleaving particular classes of damage; (4) using different lysis conditions to convert a specific class of DNA lesions into enzyme-sensitive lesions. We determined that several NNK-associated lesions can be detected with some specificity with the comet assay. For the methylation pathway, they are AP sites and the more frequent formamidopyrimidine (fapy) adducts. These fapy adducts correspond to N7-methylguanines generated in the cells that were ring-opened during the assay by the lysis solution at pH 10. For the pyridyloxobutylation pathway, alkylphosphotriesters and a roughly equal frequency of fapy sites were detected. By analogy to the methylation damage, these fapy adducts are thought to be the ring-opened form of N7-pyridyloxobutylguanines (N7-pobG). N7-pobG are unstable and this constitutes the first indirect demonstration of their formation in cells. But contrary to N7-m-fapy, the lysis time or pH did not influence the frequency of N7-pob-fapy adducts detected, suggesting that they already exist in the cells and are not related to the experimental conditions. These N7-pob-fapy have a strong mutagenic potential and we think that the comet assay, in spite of its limitations, is a good way to study them considering their low frequency and the inherent instability of the adduct from which they originate.
4-(甲基亚硝基氨基)-1-(3-吡啶基)-1-丁酮(NNK)是烟草烟雾中最具肺特异性的致癌物。它在细胞中的生物活化会导致少量的甲基化或吡啶氧基丁基化DNA损伤。鉴于其高度敏感性,彗星试验似乎是研究与NNK相关损伤的首选技术。人们采用了几种策略来赋予该试验一定的特异性:(1)使用能产生有限种类DNA损伤的类似物,因为它们模拟甲基化或吡啶氧基丁基化途径;(2)使用具有不同生物活化能力的细胞;(3)使用碱转化和/或特定的酶来切割特定类型的损伤;(4)使用不同的裂解条件将特定类型的DNA损伤转化为对酶敏感的损伤。我们确定,通过彗星试验可以以一定的特异性检测到几种与NNK相关的损伤。对于甲基化途径,它们是无嘌呤嘧啶位点和更常见的甲酰胺嘧啶(fapy)加合物。这些fapy加合物对应于细胞中产生的N7-甲基鸟嘌呤,在试验过程中,pH 10的裂解液会使其开环。对于吡啶氧基丁基化途径,检测到了烷基磷酸三酯和大致相同频率的fapy位点。类似于甲基化损伤,这些fapy加合物被认为是N7-吡啶氧基丁基鸟嘌呤(N7-pobG)的开环形式。N7-pobG不稳定,这首次间接证明了它们在细胞中的形成。但与N7-m-fapy不同的是,裂解时间或pH值不会影响检测到的N7-pob-fapy加合物的频率,这表明它们已经存在于细胞中,与实验条件无关。这些N7-pob-fapy具有很强的诱变潜力,我们认为,尽管彗星试验有其局限性,但考虑到它们的低频率以及它们所源自的加合物固有的不稳定性,它仍是研究它们的一种好方法。