Dick Bruce, Ferguson Jane, Chandra-Mouli Venkatraman, Brabin Loretta, Chatterjee Subidita, Ross David A
Department of Child and Adolescent Health and Development, WHO, Geneva, Switzerland.
World Health Organ Tech Rep Ser. 2006;938:151-204; discussion 317-41.
This chapter reviews the evidence base for interventions that aim to increase young people's use of health services in developing countries.
We identified published and unpublished studies and reports from developing countries that provided information about interventions designed to increase young people's use of health services. The studies were classified into six different types based on whether they included some or all of the following characteristics: training for service providers and clinic staff; making efforts to improve the quality of the facilities; implementing community activities to generate demand and support for the services; and involving other sectors, notably schools and the media. The levels of evidence required to make decisions about policies and programmes were defined for each of these types.
Despite the lack of detailed descriptions of interventions in the studies and difficulties interpreting the data reported in the evaluations, the studies provided evidence of increased use of health services by young people for those types of interventions that included training for service providers, making improvements to clinic facilities and implementing activities in the community, with or without the involvement of other sectors.
The evidence for the effectiveness of interventions to increase young people's use of health services was sufficient to recommend that interventions that include training for service providers, making improvements to clinics and using activities in the community should be widely implemented with careful monitoring of quality and coverage and that those that additionally involve other sectors should also be widely but cautiously implemented, provided they include a strong evaluation component. Operations research is also required to better understand the content of the interventions and their mechanisms of action.
本章回顾旨在提高发展中国家年轻人利用卫生服务水平的干预措施的证据基础。
我们识别了来自发展中国家的已发表和未发表的研究及报告,这些研究及报告提供了有关旨在提高年轻人利用卫生服务水平的干预措施的信息。根据这些研究是否包含以下部分或全部特征,将其分为六种不同类型:对服务提供者和诊所工作人员的培训;努力改善设施质量;开展社区活动以创造对服务的需求并提供支持;以及让其他部门参与,特别是学校和媒体。针对每种类型确定了制定政策和计划所需的证据水平。
尽管研究中缺乏对干预措施的详细描述,且评估报告中的数据难以解读,但这些研究为年轻人更多地利用卫生服务提供了证据,这些干预措施包括对服务提供者的培训、改善诊所设施以及在社区开展活动,无论是否有其他部门的参与。
提高年轻人利用卫生服务水平的干预措施有效性的证据足以建议,应广泛实施包括对服务提供者培训、改善诊所条件以及利用社区活动的干预措施,并仔细监测质量和覆盖范围;对于那些额外涉及其他部门的干预措施,只要包含强有力的评估部分,也应广泛但谨慎地实施。还需要开展运筹学研究,以更好地理解干预措施的内容及其作用机制。