Abraham Reem R, Kamath Asha, Upadhya Subramanya, Ramnarayan Komattil
Department of Physiology, Melaka Manipal Medical College, Manipal, Karnataka, India.
Med Educ. 2006 Sep;40(9):916-23. doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2929.2006.02547.x.
Inventories monitoring students' learning approaches are widely used in medical education research. It is important that teaching interventions adopted in medical schools aim to develop a deep approach to learning in medical students. To study the changes in medical students' approaches to learning before and after the incorporation of clinically orientated physiology teaching (COPT) in the undergraduate physiology curriculum, using the Short Inventory of Approaches to Learning (SIAL). Medical students (n = 223) at Melaka Manipal Medical College (Manipal Campus) undertake a 9-week learning block of endocrine, reproductive and renal physiology in Year 1. During this period, COPT was incorporated along with regular didactic lectures with the intention of enhancing the use of the deep approach and decreasing the use of the surface and strategic approaches to learning taken by the students. The SIAL, which focuses on the learning approaches of students to physiology, was distributed both before and after COPT. The implementation of COPT seemed to affect the learning approaches of students as measured by the SIAL. After the introduction of COPT, there was a significant increase in the use of the deep learning approach, while the majority of subscales for the surface approach showed decreased use. Nevertheless, use of the strategic approach was found to have increased after COPT. The SIAL was found to be a fairly reliable tool with which to determine the learning approaches of medical students. Clinically orientated physiology teaching was successful in enhancing use of the deep approach to learning and reducing use of the surface approach among undergraduate medical students.
监测学生学习方法的量表在医学教育研究中被广泛使用。医学院校采用的教学干预措施旨在培养医学生的深度学习方法,这一点很重要。为了研究在本科生理学课程中纳入临床导向生理学教学(COPT)前后医学生学习方法的变化,使用了《学习方法简短量表》(SIAL)。马六甲马尼帕尔医学院(马尼帕尔校区)的223名医学生在一年级时进行为期9周的内分泌、生殖和肾脏生理学学习模块。在此期间,将COPT与常规的理论讲座相结合,目的是增加学生对深度学习方法的使用,并减少他们对表面学习方法和策略性学习方法的使用。专注于学生生理学学习方法的SIAL在COPT前后都进行了发放。COPT的实施似乎影响了学生的学习方法,这通过SIAL进行衡量。引入COPT后,深度学习方法的使用显著增加,而表面学习方法的大多数子量表显示使用减少。然而,发现COPT后策略性学习方法的使用有所增加。SIAL被发现是一种相当可靠的工具,可用于确定医学生的学习方法。临床导向生理学教学成功地增加了本科医学生对深度学习方法的使用,并减少了表面学习方法的使用。