Argoud Fernanda I M, De Azevedo Fernando M, Neto José Marino, Grillo Eugênio
Biomedical Engineering Institute (IEB), Federal University of Santa Catarina (UFSC), Florianópolis, Brazil,
Med Biol Eng Comput. 2006 Jun;44(6):459-70. doi: 10.1007/s11517-006-0056-y. Epub 2006 May 4.
Interictal spike detection is a time-consuming, low-efficiency task, but is important to epilepsy diagnosis. Automated systems reported to date usually have their practical efficacy compromised by elevated rates of false-positive detections per minute, which are caused mainly by the influence of artifacts (such as noise activity and ocular movements) and by the adoption of single or simple approaches. This work describes the development of a hybrid system for automatic detection of spikes in long-term electroencephalogram (EEG), named System for Automatic Detection of Epileptiform Events in EEG (SADE(3)), which uses wavelet transform, neural networks and artificial intelligence procedures to recognize epileptic and to reject non-epileptic activity. The system's pre-processing stage filters the EEG epochs with the Coiflet wavelet function, which showed the closest correlation to epileptogenic (EPG) activity, in opposition to some other wavelet functions that did not correlate with these events. In contrast to current attempts using continuous wavelet transform, we chose to work with fast wavelet transform to reduce processing time and data volume. Detail components at appropriate decomposition levels were used to accentuate spikes, sharp waves, high-frequency noise activity and ocular artifacts. These four detailed components were used to train four specialized neural networks, designed to detect and classify the EPG and non-EPG events. An expert module analyzes the networks' outputs, together with multichannel and context information and concludes the detection. The system was evaluated with 126,000 EEG epochs, obtained from seven different patients during long-term monitoring, under diverse behavior and mental states. More than 6,721 spikes and sharp waves were previously identified by three experienced human electroencephalographers. In these tests, the SADE(3) system simultaneously achieved 70.9% sensitivity, 99.9% specificity and a rate of 0.13 false-positives per minute, indicating its usefulness and low vulnerability to artifact influence. After tests, the SADE(3) system showed itself to be able to process bipolar cortical EEG records, from long-term monitoring, up to 32 channels, without any data preparation or event positioning. At the same time, SADE(3) revealed a high capacity to reject non-epileptic paroxysms, robustness in relation to a variety of spike morphologies, flexibility in adjustment of performance rates and the capacity to actually save time during EEG reading. Furthermore, it can be adapted to other applications for pattern recognition, with simple adjustments.
发作间期棘波检测是一项耗时、低效的任务,但对癫痫诊断很重要。迄今为止报道的自动化系统通常由于每分钟误报率升高而使其实际效果受到影响,这主要是由伪迹(如噪声活动和眼球运动)的影响以及采用单一或简单方法导致的。这项工作描述了一种用于自动检测长期脑电图(EEG)中棘波的混合系统的开发,名为脑电图癫痫样事件自动检测系统(SADE(3)),该系统使用小波变换、神经网络和人工智能程序来识别癫痫活动并排除非癫痫活动。该系统的预处理阶段使用Coiflet小波函数对EEG片段进行滤波,Coiflet小波函数与致痫(EPG)活动显示出最密切的相关性,这与一些其他与这些事件不相关的小波函数形成对比。与当前使用连续小波变换的尝试不同,我们选择使用快速小波变换来减少处理时间和数据量。在适当分解级别上的细节分量用于突出棘波、尖波、高频噪声活动和眼球伪迹。这四个细节分量用于训练四个专门的神经网络,旨在检测和分类EPG和非EPG事件。一个专家模块分析网络的输出,连同多通道和上下文信息并得出检测结论。该系统使用从七名不同患者在长期监测期间、在不同行为和精神状态下获得的126,000个EEG片段进行了评估。之前由三名经验丰富的脑电图专家识别出了超过6721个棘波和尖波。在这些测试中,SADE(3)系统同时实现了70.9%的灵敏度、99.9%的特异性和每分钟0.13次的误报率,表明了其有效性以及对伪迹影响的低敏感性。测试后,SADE(3)系统表明自己能够处理来自长期监测的多达32通道的双极皮层EEG记录,无需任何数据准备或事件定位。同时,SADE(3)显示出高能力来排除非癫痫性发作,对各种棘波形态具有稳健性,可以灵活调整性能率,并且在EEG读取期间实际能够节省时间。此外,通过简单调整,它可以适用于其他模式识别应用。