Rhodes Jonathan, Curran Tracy J, Camil Laurel, Rabideau Nicole, Fulton David R, Gauthier Naomi S, Gauvreau Kimberlee, Jenkins Kathy J
Department of Cardiology, Children's Hospital, Boston, 300 Longwood Ave, Boston, Massachusetts 02115, USA.
Pediatrics. 2006 Sep;118(3):e586-93. doi: 10.1542/peds.2006-0264.
Past studies have documented the acute benefits of cardiac rehabilitation in children with congenital heart disease. It is not known whether these benefits persist.
Fifteen patients, ages 8 to 17 years, with complex congenital heart disease, whose exercise function immediately after a 12-week cardiac rehabilitation program was superior to that present on a precardiac rehabilitation exercise test, were restudied 6.9 +/- 1.6 months after completion of the cardiac rehabilitation program (approximately 1 year after the precardiac rehabilitation study). Changes in exercise function relative to baseline, precardiac rehabilitation exercise tests were also compared with changes observed in a group of 18 control subjects, with similar diagnoses, who also had 2 exercise tests separated by a year but did not undergo cardiac rehabilitation.
The cardiac rehabilitation patients' exercise function did not change significantly over the 6.9-month period after the completion of the cardiac rehabilitation program; percentage of predicted peak oxygen consumption and peak work rate remained significantly superior to baseline, precardiac rehabilitation values. These changes were also associated with improvements in self-esteem, behavior, and emotional state. In contrast, among the control subjects, small, but statistically insignificant declines in peak oxygen consumption and peak work rate were observed on the final exercise test compared with values obtained at baseline, 1 year earlier. The improvements realized by the cardiac rehabilitation patients differed significantly from the concurrent changes observed among the control subjects and appeared to be a result of an increase in the oxygen pulse at peak exercise; significant changes in peak heart rate were not observed.
In patients with congenital heart disease, cardiac rehabilitation produces significant, sustained improvements in exercise function, behavior, self-esteem, and emotional state.
既往研究记录了先天性心脏病患儿心脏康复的急性益处。但这些益处是否持续存在尚不清楚。
15例年龄在8至17岁之间的复杂先天性心脏病患者,其在为期12周的心脏康复计划结束后的运动功能优于心脏康复前运动测试时的功能,在心脏康复计划完成后6.9±1.6个月(约在心脏康复前研究后1年)接受再次研究。还将心脏康复前运动测试中相对于基线的运动功能变化与一组18名诊断相似的对照受试者的变化进行了比较,这些对照受试者也进行了两次相隔一年的运动测试,但未接受心脏康复。
心脏康复患者在心脏康复计划完成后的6.9个月期间运动功能没有显著变化;预测的峰值耗氧量和峰值工作率百分比仍显著高于基线、心脏康复前的值。这些变化还与自尊、行为和情绪状态的改善相关。相比之下,在对照受试者中,与1年前基线时获得的值相比,在最后一次运动测试中观察到峰值耗氧量和峰值工作率有小幅但无统计学意义的下降。心脏康复患者实现的改善与对照受试者中同时观察到的变化显著不同,似乎是由于峰值运动时氧脉搏增加所致;未观察到峰值心率有显著变化。
在先天性心脏病患者中,心脏康复可使运动功能、行为、自尊和情绪状态产生显著且持续的改善。