Moreland J D, Westland S
MacKay Institute, Keele University, United Kingdom.
Vis Neurosci. 2006 May-Aug;23(3-4):549-54. doi: 10.1017/S0952523806233522.
An earlier modeling study of the effect of changes in macular pigment optical density (MPOD) on a wide range of surface colors is re-examined. That study reported changes in local chromaticity variance and in color spacing, some of which were incompatible with tritan-like confusions in normals associated with high-simulated MPOD. This disagreement might have arisen through the use of the von Kries correction for adaptation. The analysis is repeated, using 1782 reflectance spectra of natural and man-made colors. These colors are segregated into an array of 25 equally populated cells in an analogue of the MacLeod-Boynton cone excitation diagram. Removing the von Kries correction restores compatibility with other experimental data. Differences between the results for normal and anomalous trichromats, noted in the earlier study, are confirmed. An analysis of local chromaticity variance across color space indicates the presence of systematic patterns. The earlier study also reported differences in results across observer types (for example, between normals and protanomals) and this is addressed here by utilizing fundamentals defined by a variable photopigment template. Chromaticities are computed for the same 1782 reflectance spectra for normals and for a set of protanomals (for whom the anomalous L pigment is shifted between the normal L and M spectral locations). Colors are segregated into an array of 100 cells in an analogue of the MacLeod-Boynton cone excitation diagram. Changes in chromaticity variance with MPOD for these cells are mapped for normals and protanomals. Variance along the L/(L + M) axis is sensitive to the number of cells used for segmentation. It also increases with MPOD for normal observers but this trend reverses as the wavelength of maximum sensitivity of the L cone shifts towards shorter wavelengths (protanomalous locations).
一项关于黄斑色素光密度(MPOD)变化对多种表面颜色影响的早期建模研究被重新审视。该研究报告了局部色度方差和颜色间距的变化,其中一些变化与正常人中与高模拟MPOD相关的类似蓝黄色混淆不相容。这种不一致可能是由于使用了冯·克里司适应校正。使用1782个天然和人造颜色的反射光谱重复了分析。这些颜色在麦克劳德 - 博因顿锥激发图的类似物中被分离成25个等数量的单元阵列。去除冯·克里司校正恢复了与其他实验数据的兼容性。早期研究中指出的正常三色视者和异常三色视者结果之间的差异得到了证实。对整个颜色空间的局部色度方差分析表明存在系统模式。早期研究还报告了不同观察者类型(例如,正常人和红色弱患者)结果的差异,这里通过利用可变光色素模板定义的基本原理来解决这一问题。针对正常人和一组红色弱患者(其异常的L色素在正常L和M光谱位置之间移动)计算了相同的1782个反射光谱的色度。颜色在麦克劳德 - 博因顿锥激发图的类似物中被分离成100个单元阵列。针对这些单元,绘制了正常人和红色弱患者色度方差随MPOD的变化。沿L/(L + M)轴的方差对用于分割的单元数量敏感。对于正常观察者,它也随MPOD增加,但随着L锥最大敏感度波长向更短波长移动(红色弱位置),这种趋势会逆转。