Dale Paul S, Graham Joe, Nichols Kirt W, Catchings Tim, Richards Michael
Department of Surgery, Division of Surgical Oncology, Ellis Fischel Cancer Center, 115 Business Loop 70 W., DC 116.94, University of Missouri School of Medicine, Columbia, MO 65203, USA.
Am J Surg. 2006 Oct;192(4):488-91. doi: 10.1016/j.amjsurg.2006.07.001.
Peripheral vascular disease (PVD) is a progressive and debilitating disease often diagnosed only when patients become symptomatic. Currently there are no widespread screening tests available for the early detection of PVD. Patients with diabetes and coronary artery disease are known to have a higher incidence of PVD. Prior studies have indicated that benign vascular calcifications seen on routine screening mammogram are more prevalent in women with diabetes and coronary artery disease. The same association has not been shown for women with PVD. The purpose of this study was to identify an association between benign vascular calcifications identified on mammography and PVD. If such an association exists then screening mammography, already widely used as a screening tool for breast cancer, may identify women at high risk for PVD.
To determine the incidence of vascular calcifications in our general screening population we prospectively evaluated consecutive routine screening mammograms for the presence of benign vascular calcifications. We then identified a population of women with PVD by using a computerized database maintained by the Division of Vascular Surgery. The population of women identified with PVD was categorized further to identify those women who had received routine screening mammogram within our hospital system. These mammograms were reviewed retrospectively with particular attention to the presence of vascular calcifications. All mammograms were reviewed by our dedicated mammographers. Statistical analysis of the study group using the chi-square test was performed to determine the association of PVD and mammographic vascular calcifications.
Prospective evaluation of 645 women undergoing consecutive routine screening mammography identified 123 (19%) with benign vascular calcifications. By using our PVD computerized database between the years 2002 and 2004 we identified 763 women with PVD. Of this group only 121 (15%) had undergone a routine screening mammogram in our hospital system. These mammograms were reviewed retrospectively by the same group evaluating the screening mammograms. On evaluation vascular calcifications were identified in 42% (51 of 121) of these women with PVD. Statistical analysis was performed using the chi-square test, odds ratio, and relative risk. A highly significant association was identified between PVD and the presence of mammographic vascular calcifications (P > .001). With a confidence interval of 95% the presence of benign vascular microcalcifications on routine screening mammogram identifies a significant risk for PVD with an odds ratio of 3.06. We showed through our analysis that women with calcifications are 2.19 times more likely to have PVD if microcalcifications are present. By using vascular calcifications identified on screening mammography as a means to identify women with PVD the sensitivity and specificity are 42% and 80%, respectively. The positive predictive value and the negative predictive value are 29% and 88%, respectively, with an accuracy of 75%.
This initial study indicates that the presence of vascular calcifications identified on routine screening mammogram is significantly higher in women with PVD and the lack of vascular calcifications on screening mammography correlates well with a negative history of PVD. We have identified a significant association with PVD and vascular calcifications in our patient population. Further studies are indicated to determine if screening mammography may become a widespread inexpensive screening tool to identify women at risk for PVD. Additional studies are underway at our institution to evaluate the association of PVD, diabetes and coronary artery disease, and vascular calcifications identified on routine screening mammography.
外周血管疾病(PVD)是一种渐进性的衰弱疾病,通常仅在患者出现症状时才被诊断出来。目前尚无广泛应用的筛查测试可用于早期检测PVD。已知糖尿病和冠状动脉疾病患者患PVD的几率更高。先前的研究表明,在常规筛查乳房X光检查中发现的良性血管钙化在糖尿病和冠状动脉疾病女性中更为普遍。但尚未发现PVD女性存在同样的关联。本研究的目的是确定乳房X光检查中发现的良性血管钙化与PVD之间的关联。如果存在这种关联,那么已广泛用作乳腺癌筛查工具的筛查乳房X光检查可能会识别出PVD高危女性。
为了确定我们一般筛查人群中血管钙化的发生率,我们前瞻性地评估了连续的常规筛查乳房X光片,以检查是否存在良性血管钙化。然后,我们使用血管外科维护的计算机数据库确定了一组PVD女性。对确定患有PVD的女性人群进行进一步分类,以识别那些在我们医院系统内接受过常规筛查乳房X光检查的女性。对这些乳房X光片进行回顾性审查,特别关注血管钙化的存在。所有乳房X光片均由我们专门的乳房X光摄影师进行审查。使用卡方检验对研究组进行统计分析,以确定PVD与乳房X光血管钙化之间是否存在关联。
对645名接受连续常规筛查乳房X光检查的女性进行前瞻性评估,发现123名(19%)存在良性血管钙化。通过使用我们的PVD计算机数据库,在2002年至2004年期间,我们确定了763名PVD女性。在这组人群中,只有121名(15%)在我们医院系统接受过常规筛查乳房X光检查。这些乳房X光片由评估筛查乳房X光片的同一组人员进行回顾性审查。在评估中,这些PVD女性中有42%(121名中的51名)被发现有血管钙化。使用卡方检验、优势比和相对风险进行统计分析。发现PVD与乳房X光血管钙化的存在之间存在高度显著的关联(P>.001)。在95%的置信区间内,常规筛查乳房X光检查中存在良性血管微钙化表明患PVD的风险显著增加,优势比为3.06。我们通过分析表明,如果存在微钙化,有钙化的女性患PVD的可能性是前者的2.19倍。将筛查乳房X光检查中发现的血管钙化作为识别PVD女性的一种方法,其敏感性和特异性分别为42%和80%。阳性预测值和阴性预测值分别为29%和88%,准确率为75%。
这项初步研究表明,在常规筛查乳房X光检查中发现血管钙化的情况在PVD女性中显著更高,而筛查乳房X光检查中没有血管钙化与PVD阴性病史密切相关。我们已经确定在我们的患者人群中PVD与血管钙化之间存在显著关联。需要进一步研究以确定筛查乳房X光检查是否可能成为一种广泛使用的廉价筛查工具,用于识别PVD高危女性。我们机构正在进行其他研究,以评估PVD、糖尿病和冠状动脉疾病以及常规筛查乳房X光检查中发现的血管钙化之间的关联。