Scott Lisa S, Tanaka James W, Sheinberg David L, Curran Tim
University of Colorado, Boulder, USA.
J Cogn Neurosci. 2006 Sep;18(9):1453-65. doi: 10.1162/jocn.2006.18.9.1453.
Subordinate-level object processing is regarded as a hallmark of perceptual expertise. However, the relative contribution of subordinate- and basic-level category experience in the acquisition of perceptual expertise has not been clearly delineated. In this study, participants learned to classify wading birds and owls at either the basic (e.g., wading bird, owl) or the subordinate (e.g., egret, snowy owl) level. After 6 days of training, behavioral results showed that subordinate-level but not basic-level training improved subordinate discrimination of trained exemplars, novel exemplars, and exemplars from novel species. Event-related potentials indicated that both basic- and subordinate-level training enhanced the early N170 component, but only subordinate-level training amplified the later N250 component. These results are consistent with models positing separate basic and subordinate learning mechanisms, and, contrary to perspectives attempting to explain visual expertise solely in terms of subordinate-level processing, suggest that expertise enhances neural responses of both basic and subordinate processing.
下属层级的物体加工被视为感知专长的一个标志。然而,下属层级和基础层级类别经验在感知专长习得过程中的相对贡献尚未得到明确界定。在本研究中,参与者学习对涉禽和猫头鹰在基础层级(如涉禽、猫头鹰)或下属层级(如白鹭、雪鸮)进行分类。经过6天的训练,行为结果表明,下属层级而非基础层级的训练提高了对训练样本、新样本以及来自新物种样本的下属层级辨别能力。事件相关电位表明,基础层级和下属层级的训练均增强了早期的N170成分,但只有下属层级的训练放大了后期的N250成分。这些结果与提出单独的基础和下属学习机制的模型一致,并且与试图仅根据下属层级加工来解释视觉专长的观点相反,表明专长增强了基础和下属加工的神经反应。