Taylor's method: a therapeutic alternative for perforated gastroduodenal ulcer.

BACKGROUND/AIMS: In the context of actual trends towards an efficient and less aggressive therapy of peptic ulcer, it seems that Taylor's method, in selected cases of perforated gastroduodenal ulcers (PGDU), comes again into attention. The aim of this study was to present our 16 years' experience with Taylor's treatment as an efficient option for sealed perforated ulcers, and to highlight the indications and advantages of this method.

METHODOLOGY

A retrospective study, and prospective since 1990, was carried out on a series of 64 patients out of 592 (10%) diagnosed with PGDU between 1987 and 2003. The patients were carefully evaluated, particularly looking for clinical, laboratory and imaging diagnosis factors, indicating potential candidates for conservative approach: short history, hydropneumoperitoneum in small amount on admission. Two thirds of the patients presented in the Emergency Unit less than 12 hours from the onset of the symptoms. The diagnosis of PGDU was established by corroborating the obvious symptoms and abdominal signs with erect chest X-ray and ultrasonography (US) of the abdomen. The efficiency of Taylor's method, consisting of nasogastric aspiration, fluids resuscitation, parenteral broad spectrum antibiotics and antisecretory drugs, was assessed by meticulous repeated physical examinations, dynamics of WBC (white blood cell) and US. In case of failure, this method remained as a part of preoperative treatment.

RESULTS

The method was successful in 57 out of 64 (89%) cases of perforated peptic ulcer disease, selected from the 592 cases admitted with perforated peptic ulcer following the clinical and imaging criteria previously mentioned. The presence of pneumoperitoneum certifies the diagnosis of PGDU, but the amount of peritoneal fluid assessed by US predicts the success of the procedure. Seven patients developed complications (10.9%), mainly intraabdominal abscesses and only four of them needed surgical drainage. The mortality was nil. After discharge all patients were referred to gastroenterologists for monitoring the medical treatment and no recurrence was encountered.

CONCLUSIONS

The Taylor's method is a reliable alternative in selected cases of perforated gastroduodenal ulcers, the main advantage being the avoidance of anesthetic and surgical stress with their potential morbidity and mortality.