Grady Sue C
Geography Department, Michigan State University, 130 Geography Building, East Lansing, MI 48824, USA.
Soc Sci Med. 2006 Dec;63(12):3013-29. doi: 10.1016/j.socscimed.2006.08.017. Epub 2006 Sep 25.
This study investigates the geography of racial disparities in low birthweight in New York City by focusing on racial residential segregation and its effect on the risk of low birthweight among African-American infants and mothers. This cross-sectional multilevel analysis uses birth records at the individual level (n=96,882) and racial isolation indices at the census tract or neighborhood level (n=2095) to measure their independent and cross-level effects on low birthweight. This study found that residential segregation and neighborhood poverty operate at different scales to increase the risk of low birthweight. At the neighborhood scale residential segregation is positively and significantly associated with low birthweight, after controlling for individual-level risk factors and neighborhood poverty. Residential segregation explains neighborhood variation in low birthweight means and race effects across census tracts, which cannot be accounted for by neighborhood poverty alone. At the individual scale-increasing levels of residential segregation does not significantly reduce or exacerbate individual-level risk factors for low birthweight; whereas increasing levels of neighborhood poverty significantly eliminates the race effect and reduces the protective effect of being foreign-born on low birthweight, after controlling for other individual-level risk factors and residential segregation. These findings are contradictory to previous health research that shows protective mechanisms associated with ethnic density in local areas. It is likely that structural factors underlying residential segregation, i.e., racial isolation, impose additional stressors on African-American women that may offset or disguise positive attributes associated with ethnic density. However, as poverty is concentrated within these neighborhoods, differences between races in low birthweight cease to exist. This study demonstrates that residential segregation and neighborhood poverty are important determinants of racial disparity in low birthweight in New York City.
本研究通过关注种族居住隔离及其对非裔美国婴儿和母亲低体重出生风险的影响,调查了纽约市低体重出生方面的种族差异地理分布。这项横断面多层次分析使用了个体层面的出生记录(n = 96,882)以及普查区或社区层面的种族隔离指数(n = 2095),以衡量它们对低体重出生的独立影响和跨层次影响。本研究发现,居住隔离和社区贫困在不同尺度上发挥作用,增加了低体重出生的风险。在社区尺度上,在控制了个体层面的风险因素和社区贫困之后,居住隔离与低体重出生呈正相关且具有显著相关性。居住隔离解释了普查区之间低体重出生均值的社区差异以及种族影响,而这仅靠社区贫困是无法解释的。在个体尺度上,居住隔离程度的增加并不会显著降低或加剧低体重出生的个体层面风险因素;而在控制了其他个体层面的风险因素和居住隔离之后,社区贫困程度的增加会显著消除种族影响,并降低外国出生对低体重出生的保护作用。这些发现与之前显示当地族群密度具有保护机制的健康研究相矛盾。居住隔离背后的结构因素,即种族隔离,可能会给非裔美国女性带来额外压力,这些压力可能会抵消或掩盖与族群密度相关的积极属性。然而,由于贫困集中在这些社区内,低体重出生方面的种族差异就不复存在了。本研究表明,居住隔离和社区贫困是纽约市低体重出生种族差异的重要决定因素。