Chang Sun O, Choi Byung Yoon, Hur Dong Gu
Department of Otolaryngology, Seoul National University National University Hospital, Seoul, Korea.
Laryngoscope. 2006 Oct;116(10):1835-41. doi: 10.1097/01.mlg.0000233703.52308.73.
Careful surgical candidate selection guarantees a high probability of serviceable hearing postoperatively in congenital aural atresia (CAA) patients. The authors analyzed hearing results after CAA surgery with long-term follow-up (F/U) with respect to several clinical factors.
This was a retrospective study.
The medical records of 93 CAA patients (100 ears) who underwent operations from January 1987 through December 2002 at Seoul National University Hospital were reviewed. Mean duration was 56.9 months. The authors evaluated the results of hearing after surgery over 3 year F/U with a view to clarifying the factors accounting for unsuccessful results.
Approximately 64% of patients treated surgically achieved a considerable hearing gain over long-term F/U. Postoperative hearing remained relatively stable over the period from 6 months to 3 years postoperatively, yielding only 2.75 dB of aggravation. However, hearing results in revision cases deteriorated with time, which led to statistically higher air-conduction thresholds than those of primary cases at the 1 and 3 year F/Us. Resultantly, only 26.6% of patients having achieved a poor hearing gain post first surgery benefited from revision audiologically. The severity of microtia was found to help predict poor long-term hearing outcomes after CAA surgery.
Nonrevision cases and cases with mild microtia appear to have acceptable and stable long-term hearing results. Disappointing long-term hearing results in revision, and severe microtia cases should lead to considerations of alternative options in these cases, such as bone-anchored hearing aids, which offer reliable and stable results.
精心挑选手术候选者可提高先天性耳道闭锁(CAA)患者术后获得可用听力的可能性。作者分析了CAA手术后长期随访(F/U)的听力结果与多种临床因素的关系。
这是一项回顾性研究。
回顾了1987年1月至2002年12月在首尔国立大学医院接受手术的93例CAA患者(100耳)的病历。平均随访时间为56.9个月。作者评估了术后3年随访的听力结果,以明确导致手术结果不佳的因素。
在长期随访中,约64%接受手术治疗的患者听力有显著提高。术后6个月至3年期间,听力保持相对稳定,仅加重2.75分贝。然而,再次手术病例的听力结果随时间恶化,在1年和3年随访时,其气导阈值在统计学上高于初次手术病例。结果,首次手术后听力改善不佳的患者中,只有26.6%在再次听力检查中受益。发现小耳畸形的严重程度有助于预测CAA手术后长期听力不佳的结果。
未进行再次手术的病例和小耳畸形较轻的病例似乎有可接受且稳定的长期听力结果。再次手术病例和严重小耳畸形病例令人失望的长期听力结果应促使在这些病例中考虑其他选择,如骨锚式助听器,其能提供可靠且稳定的结果。