Liss P, Persson P B, Hansell P, Lagerqvist B
Institute of Radiology, University of Uppsala, Uppsala, Sweden.
Kidney Int. 2006 Nov;70(10):1811-7. doi: 10.1038/sj.ki.5001887. Epub 2006 Sep 27.
We compared the Swedish Coronary Angiography and Angioplasty Registry with the Swedish 'Hospital Discharge Register' to assess contrast media (CM)-induced renal failure. Hospitals used only one type CM. From 2000 to 2003, iodixanol (iso-osmolar) was used in 45 485 patients, ioxaglate (low osmolar) in 12 440 subjects. To include the earlier used CM iohexol (low osmolar), analysis extended back to 1990 (86 334 patients). Incidence of clinically significant renal failure was greatest for patients receiving the iso-osmolar CM iodixanol (1.7%). Ioxaglate-treated patients had a significantly lower renal failure incidence (0.8%, P<0.001). The odds ratio for iodixanol-treated patients was significantly higher than for ioxaglate (1 vs 0.48, P<0.001). In subsets of either diabetic patients or patients with previous renal failure, odds ratios for renal failure remained greater in the iodixanol groups (P<0.01). Hospitals switching CM to iodixanol experienced a doubling in clinically significant renal failure after cardiac procedures. Dialysis was required in 0.2% of patients receiving iodixanol, which was significantly higher (P<0.01) than for ioxaglate-treated patients (0.1%). Iohexol-treated patients had a similar low risk for developing clinically significant renal failure (0.9%) as ioxaglate. In conclusion, risk of developing renal failure and required dialysis after coronary procedures is higher when patients received iodixanol than ioxaglate or iohexol.
我们将瑞典冠状动脉造影和血管成形术注册数据库与瑞典“医院出院登记册”进行比较,以评估造影剂(CM)诱发的肾衰竭。各医院仅使用一种类型的造影剂。2000年至2003年,45485例患者使用了碘克沙醇(等渗),12440例患者使用了碘克酸(低渗)。为纳入早期使用的造影剂碘海醇(低渗),分析追溯至1990年(86334例患者)。接受等渗造影剂碘克沙醇的患者发生具有临床意义的肾衰竭的发生率最高(1.7%)。接受碘克酸治疗的患者肾衰竭发生率显著较低(0.8%,P<0.001)。碘克沙醇治疗患者的比值比显著高于碘克酸治疗患者(1比0.48,P<0.001)。在糖尿病患者或既往有肾衰竭的患者亚组中,碘克沙醇组肾衰竭的比值比仍然更高(P<0.01)。将造影剂更换为碘克沙醇的医院在心脏手术后发生具有临床意义的肾衰竭的情况增加了一倍。接受碘克沙醇治疗的患者中有0.2%需要透析,这显著高于(P<0.01)接受碘克酸治疗的患者(0.1%)。接受碘海醇治疗的患者发生具有临床意义的肾衰竭的风险与接受碘克酸治疗的患者相似(0.9%)。总之,冠状动脉手术后患者接受碘克沙醇时发生肾衰竭和需要透析的风险高于接受碘克酸或碘海醇时。