Muller-Bolla M, Collet J P, Ducruet T, Robinson A
Centre for Clinical Epidemiology and Community Studies, Randomized Clinical Trial Unit, Jewish General Hospital, McGill University, Montreal, Canada.
Undersea Hyperb Med. 2006 Jul-Aug;33(4):237-44.
This article reports the side effects observed in a double-blind placebo-controlled multi-center randomized clinical trial carried out to assess the efficacy and safety of hyperbaric oxygen (HBO2) therapy in children with cerebral palsy. Intention-to-treat analysis did not prove to have a beneficial effect.
111 children aged 3 to 12 years were included and followed for 8 weeks. They all received 40 compressions of 1 hour (5 days per week). In the treated group (n=57), HBO2 sessions consisted of an exposure to 100% oxygen at 1.75 atmosphere absolute (atm abs) while children in the control group (n=54) received air at 1.3 atm abs. A physician carried out a general health surveillance including an ear examination prior to and immediately following each session. All clinical events occurring during the course of the study were recorded.
Events were classified in 3 categories: Events related to pressure/volume changes, events related to oxygen toxicity, and other events. No events due to oxygen toxicity were noted. Only middle ear barotrauma significantly differed according to the groups (50% in HBO2 session group versus 27.8% in control group). Other events were rare and equivalent in both groups.
Short-term exposure to HBO2 at medium level pressure (1.75 atm abs) was responsible for a significant increase of middle ear barotrauma compared to children that received very low external pressure (1.3 atm abs).
本文报告了一项双盲安慰剂对照多中心随机临床试验中观察到的副作用,该试验旨在评估高压氧(HBO2)疗法对脑瘫儿童的疗效和安全性。意向性分析未证明有有益效果。
纳入111名3至12岁儿童并随访8周。他们均接受40次1小时的加压(每周5天)。治疗组(n = 57)的HBO2治疗包括在绝对压力1.75个大气压(atm abs)下暴露于100%氧气,而对照组(n = 54)的儿童在1.3 atm abs下接受空气。每次治疗前和治疗后,由一名医生进行全面健康监测,包括耳部检查。记录研究过程中发生的所有临床事件。
事件分为3类:与压力/容积变化相关的事件、与氧中毒相关的事件和其他事件。未发现因氧中毒导致的事件。仅中耳气压伤在两组间有显著差异(HBO2治疗组为50%,对照组为27.8%)。其他事件很少见,且两组相当。
与接受极低外部压力(1.3 atm abs)的儿童相比,中等压力水平(1.75 atm abs)下短期暴露于HBO2会导致中耳气压伤显著增加。