Beurskens Carien H G, Heymans Peter G, Oostendorp Rob A B
Department of Physiotherapy, Radboud University Nijmegen Medical Centre, Nijmegen, The Netherlands.
Otol Neurotol. 2006 Oct;27(7):1037-42. doi: 10.1097/01.mao.0000217350.09796.07.
To assess the stability of benefits of mime therapy, a modality of physiotherapy for patients with facial nerve paresis, during a period of 1 year.
A prospective follow-up build on a randomized clinical trial in which a treatment group is compared with a control group.
Physiotherapy outpatient department.
Forty-eight patients with a history of a facial nerve paresis of 9 months or more.
Mime therapy.
Sequelae of facial nerve paresis were measured using the same measurement instruments as in the randomized clinical trial--the Sunnybrook and the House-Brackmann (HB) Facial Grading Systems, the lip length and pout indices, a stiffness scale, and the Facial Disability Index. Stability of outcome level and of interpatient differences is analyzed.
Of the 46 patients who completed the follow-ups, repeated-measures analyses of covariance revealed no significant differences in the average scores nor significant trends of the posttherapy measurements, except for the pout index and the Facial Disability Index-social. For six sequelae (except HB), 95% of patient-sequel combinations showed immediate improvement after mime therapy, for HB grades this was 74%. Where sequelae improved, the posttherapy individual courses (T2-T3-T4) showed, also for HB, in majority absence of deterioration; benefits obtained were stable.
Mime therapy is effective in patients with facial nerve paresis and benefits are stable 1 year after therapy.
评估哑剧疗法(一种用于面神经麻痹患者的物理治疗方式)在1年期间疗效的稳定性。
基于一项随机临床试验进行前瞻性随访,将治疗组与对照组进行比较。
物理治疗门诊部。
48例有9个月或更长时间面神经麻痹病史的患者。
哑剧疗法。
使用与随机临床试验相同的测量工具——桑尼布鲁克和豪斯-布拉克曼(HB)面部分级系统、唇长和撅嘴指数、僵硬程度量表以及面部残疾指数,对面神经麻痹后遗症进行测量。分析结果水平和患者间差异的稳定性。
在完成随访的46例患者中,重复测量协方差分析显示,除撅嘴指数和面部残疾指数-社交方面外,治疗后测量的平均得分无显著差异,也无显著趋势。对于六种后遗症(HB除外),95%的患者-后遗症组合在哑剧疗法后立即有改善,对于HB分级,这一比例为74%。在后遗症有所改善的情况下,治疗后的个体病程(T2-T3-T4),同样对于HB分级,大多数情况下没有恶化;所获得的疗效是稳定的。
哑剧疗法对面神经麻痹患者有效,且治疗1年后疗效稳定。