Elkind Arthur H, O'Carroll Philip, Blumenfeld Andrew, DeGryse Ronald, Dimitrova Rozalina
Elkind Headache Center, Mount Vernon, New York, USA.
J Pain. 2006 Oct;7(10):688-96. doi: 10.1016/j.jpain.2006.03.002.
We examined the effects of multiple treatments with low doses of botulinum toxin type A (BoNTA; BOTOX(R), Allergan Inc., Irvine, CA) versus placebo for prophylaxis of episodic migraine. This was a series of 3 sequential, randomized, controlled studies of 418 patients with a history of 4 to 8 moderate to severe migraines per month. In study I, patients were randomized to treatment with placebo or BoNTA (7.5 U, 25 U, or 50 U) in predetermined fixed injection sites on the front and sides of the head only. In study II, patients continued to receive, or were randomized to, 2 consecutive treatments with 25 U or 50 U. In study III, patients were randomized to placebo or continuation of 25 U or 50 U. Injection cycles were each 4 months long. BoNTA and placebo produced comparable decreases from baseline in the frequency of migraines at each time point examined (P >or= .201). No consistent, statistically significant differences were observed for any efficacy variable. Adverse events were similar among the groups within each study. In these exploratory studies of episodic migraine patients, repeated injections of low doses of BoNTA into fixed frontal, temporal, and glabellar sites were not more effective than placebo. BoNTA was safe and well tolerated.
Beneficial effects of BoNTA in the treatment of migraine have been reported, but positive results are not universal, possibly because the optimal patient population and regimen are not yet definitively established. This study explores the effects of multiple injections of low BoNTA doses into fixed sites for episodic migraine.
我们研究了低剂量A型肉毒毒素(BoNTA;保妥适®,艾尔建公司,加利福尼亚州欧文市)多次治疗与安慰剂预防发作性偏头痛的效果。这是对418名每月有4至8次中度至重度偏头痛病史患者进行的一系列3项连续、随机、对照研究。在研究I中,患者被随机分配接受安慰剂或BoNTA(7.5单位、25单位或50单位)治疗,仅在头部前方和两侧预先确定的固定注射部位注射。在研究II中,患者继续接受或被随机分配接受25单位或50单位的连续两次治疗。在研究III中,患者被随机分配接受安慰剂或继续接受25单位或50单位治疗。注射周期均为4个月。在每个检查时间点,BoNTA和安慰剂使偏头痛频率从基线的下降幅度相当(P≥0.201)。对于任何疗效变量,均未观察到一致的、具有统计学意义的差异。各研究组之间的不良事件相似。在这些发作性偏头痛患者的探索性研究中,在固定的额部、颞部和眉间部位重复注射低剂量BoNTA并不比安慰剂更有效。BoNTA安全且耐受性良好。
已有报道称BoNTA在治疗偏头痛方面有有益效果,但阳性结果并不普遍,可能是因为尚未明确确定最佳患者群体和治疗方案。本研究探讨了在固定部位多次注射低剂量BoNTA对发作性偏头痛的影响。