Mori Kensaku, Takahashi Nobuyuki, Hiratsuka Makiko, Shiigai Masanari, Minami Manabu, Oda Tatsuya, Ohkohchi Nobuhiro, Morishita Yukio
Department of Diagnostic and Interventional Radiology, Institute of Clinical Medicine, University of Tsukuba, Tsukuba, Japan.
J Magn Reson Imaging. 2006 Nov;24(5):1110-6. doi: 10.1002/jmri.20755.
To evaluate the diagnostic accuracy of a ferucarbotran-enhanced three-dimensional sensitivity-encoding water-excitation multishot echo-planar sequence (3D-SWEEP) for detecting hepatic metastases compared to a T2*-weighted fast field-echo (FFE) sequence.
Twenty-five consecutive patients with hepatic metastases underwent ferucarbotran-enhanced MRI on a 1.5-T unit before hepatic resections. Eighty-two foci of metastases were confirmed by histopathology or intraoperative ultrasonography (US). Signal-intensity decay (SID), tumor-to-liver contrast (TLC), and image quality were compared between T2*-weighted FFE and 3D-SWEEP. Three independent observers reviewed three imaging sets: set 1, without 3D-SWEEP or T2*-weighted FFE; set 2, with T2*-weighted FFE; and set 3, with 3D-SWEEP. The mean values of areas under alternative free response receiver operating characteristic curves (Az) and sensitivities were compared among the three sets.
SID and TLC were significantly greater for 3D-SWEEP than T2*-weighted FFE, although 3D-SWEEP had poorer image quality. The mean Az and sensitivity were significantly greater for set 3 compared to set 1 for detecting overall lesions, and compared to sets 1 and 2 for detecting lesions of 1-2 cm in diameter.
Despite relatively prominent artifacts, ferucarbotran-enhanced 3D-SWEEP was more sensitive and accurate than T2*-weighted FFE for detecting hepatic metastases.
与T2*加权快速场回波(FFE)序列相比,评估钆贝葡胺增强的三维敏感性编码水激发多激发回波平面序列(3D-SWEEP)检测肝转移瘤的诊断准确性。
25例连续的肝转移瘤患者在肝切除术前于1.5-T设备上行钆贝葡胺增强MRI检查。82个转移灶经组织病理学或术中超声(US)证实。比较T2加权FFE和3D-SWEEP之间的信号强度衰减(SID)、肿瘤与肝脏对比度(TLC)及图像质量。三位独立观察者对三组影像进行评估:第1组,无3D-SWEEP或T2加权FFE;第2组,有T2*加权FFE;第3组,有3D-SWEEP。比较三组间替代自由反应接收者操作特征曲线下面积(Az)和敏感度的平均值。
尽管3D-SWEEP图像质量较差,但其SID和TLC显著高于T2*加权FFE。第3组检测总体病灶时的平均Az和敏感度显著高于第1组,检测直径1-2 cm病灶时显著高于第1组和第2组。
尽管钆贝葡胺增强的3D-SWEEP存在相对明显的伪影,但在检测肝转移瘤方面比T2*加权FFE更敏感、准确。