Orhan K S, Demirel T, Baslo B, Orhan E K, Yücel E A, Güldiken Y, Değer K
Capa Hospital, Istanbul, Turkey.
J Laryngol Otol. 2007 Jan;121(1):44-8. doi: 10.1017/S0022215106002052. Epub 2006 Jul 3.
The aim of this study was to evaluate spinal accessory nerve function after functional neck dissection (FND) and radical neck dissection (RND) by monitoring the nerve with electromyographic (EMG) examinations. A prospective, double-blind, clinical study was undertaken in 21 patients (42 neck side dissections) operated on for head and neck malignant diseases, separated into two groups: 10 neck sides in the RND group and 32 neck sides in the FND group. Electromyographic examinations were performed pre-operatively and post-operatively in the third week and third and ninth months. Additionally, a questionnaire, modified from the neck dissection impairment index, was applied to all the patients in order to assess shoulder function in the ninth post-operative month. All patients had maximum EMG scores pre-operatively. Following the operation, motor amplitudes decreased in both groups. At the third post-operative month, amplitudes decreased to their lowest values. As expected, the decreases in amplitude and EMG score were more prominent in the RND group. Following reinnervation, the amplitudes of the trapezius motor response increased in the FND group but never reached pre-operative values (during the time of follow up). The FND group scores for pain, neck and shoulder stiffness, and disability in heavy object lifting, light object lifting and reaching overhead were significantly lower than those of the RND group. In FND, one aims to preserve anatomically the spinal accessory nerve, and it is presumed to be intact after the procedure. However, using EMG nerve function monitoring, our study revealed that profound spinal nerve injury was detected immediately after FND surgery, which tended to improve over subsequent months but had not regained its original function by the end of the ninth post-operative month.
本研究的目的是通过肌电图(EMG)检查监测神经,评估功能性颈清扫术(FND)和根治性颈清扫术(RND)后副神经的功能。对21例接受头颈部恶性疾病手术的患者(42侧颈部清扫)进行了一项前瞻性、双盲临床研究,分为两组:RND组10侧颈部,FND组32侧颈部。在术前、术后第三周以及第三和第九个月进行肌电图检查。此外,采用从颈清扫损伤指数修改而来的问卷对所有患者进行调查,以评估术后第九个月的肩部功能。所有患者术前肌电图评分均为最大值。术后两组的运动幅度均下降。术后第三个月,幅度降至最低值。正如预期的那样,RND组的幅度和肌电图评分下降更为明显。神经再支配后,FND组斜方肌运动反应的幅度增加,但在随访期间从未达到术前值。FND组在疼痛、颈部和肩部僵硬以及重物提起、轻物提起和伸手过头等方面的残疾评分明显低于RND组。在FND中,目标是在解剖学上保留副神经,并且假定术后该神经完好无损。然而,通过肌电图神经功能监测,我们的研究发现,FND手术后立即检测到严重的脊神经损伤,这种损伤在随后几个月有改善趋势,但在术后第九个月末仍未恢复到原始功能。