Splavski Bruno, Vranković Duro, Saftić Robert, Muzević Dario, Kosuta Maja, Gmajnić Rudika
Odjel za neurokirurgiju Klinicka bolnica Osijek Josipa Huttlera 4 31000 Osijek, Hrvatska.
Acta Med Croatica. 2006 Sep;60(4):369-73.
The purpose of this retrospective study was to review and discuss the outcome of surgical management and other clinical predictors influencing the prognosis of war missile penetrating brain injuries.
To determine clinical predictors that influence the prognosis of war missile penetrating brain injury, 126 surgically treated patients who had sustained such an injury during the two-year period of war in Croatia (1991-1993) were retrospectively analyzed. Investigated clinical features were: Glasgow Coma Scale (GCS) score on admission; extent of brain injury; time between injury and hospital admission; presence of intracranially retained foreign bodies or bone fragments; development of postinjury and posttraumatic complications; and Glasgow Outcome Score (GOS) at six-month follow up. The data were statistically analyzed.
Sixty-seven patients survived penetrating missile brain injury, in most of them with GCS score above 8 on admission. The mean time interval to hospital admission in this group of patients was less than two hours. Twelve of 67 patients developed different complications. All patients recovered well according to GOS (GOS 5 and 4) at six-month follow up. Fifty-nine patients died. The wounded who were in moribund state on the hospital admission (n = 11), and those who died during surgery (n = 8) were excluded from the analysis. The remaining 40 patients who did not survive were analyzed. The majority of them had GCS score 3-8 on admission. They mostly sustained bilateral hemispheric lesion, and/or ventricular lesion, and developed brain edema. The mean time interval between injury and hospital admission was over two hours in this group of patients. Postoperative complication developed in 9 of 40 patients.
The patients with GCS score exceeding 8 had by far more favorable outcome in comparison to those with GCS score less than 8. Considering the extent of injury, patients suffering unihemispheric brain wounds had a more favorable outcome than those with lesions of both hemispheres, and particularly those with transventricular lesions. The time between injury and hospital admission proved to be another important prognostic factor. The majority of patients admitted up to one hour of injury survived, while two thirds of those admitted between one and three hours of injury succumbed. The presence of intracranially retained foreign bodies and bone fragments, and postinjury and postoperative complications implied worse outcome in comparison with their absence.
The state of consciousness on admission was the most sensitive criterion as far as the prognosis is concerned. The outcome also depended on the extent of brain damage since the wounds associated with a high mortality rate were predominantly bihemispheric. Concerning survival, the time between injury and hospital admission also appeared to be important, as well as intracranially retained foreign bodies and bone fragments, and development of complications. There was no relationship between the presence of retained fragments and development of infection, suggesting that it is not necessary to reoperate for retained fragments. We assume that early surgery is essential for treatment outcome, although it is not necessary to reoperate for retained fragments.
本回顾性研究的目的是回顾和讨论手术治疗的结果以及影响战争导弹穿透性脑损伤预后的其他临床预测因素。
为确定影响战争导弹穿透性脑损伤预后的临床预测因素,对在克罗地亚战争期间(1991 - 1993年)两年内接受手术治疗的126例此类损伤患者进行了回顾性分析。所研究的临床特征包括:入院时的格拉斯哥昏迷量表(GCS)评分;脑损伤程度;受伤至入院的时间;颅内是否存在残留异物或骨碎片;伤后及创伤后并发症的发生情况;以及六个月随访时的格拉斯哥预后评分(GOS)。对数据进行了统计学分析。
67例患者在穿透性导弹脑损伤后存活,其中大多数入院时GCS评分高于8分。该组患者入院的平均时间间隔小于两小时。67例患者中有12例出现了不同的并发症。所有患者在六个月随访时根据GOS(GOS 5和4)恢复良好。59例患者死亡。入院时处于濒死状态的伤员(n = 11)以及手术期间死亡的患者(n = 8)被排除在分析之外。对其余40例未存活的患者进行了分析。他们中的大多数入院时GCS评分为3 - 8分。他们大多遭受双侧半球损伤和/或脑室损伤,并出现了脑水肿。该组患者受伤至入院的平均时间间隔超过两小时。40例患者中有9例发生了术后并发症。
与GCS评分低于8分的患者相比,GCS评分超过8分的患者预后明显更好。考虑到损伤程度,单半球脑损伤患者的预后比双侧半球损伤患者,尤其是脑室贯通伤患者更有利。受伤至入院的时间被证明是另一个重要的预后因素。大多数在受伤后一小时内入院的患者存活,而在受伤后一至三小时入院的患者中有三分之二死亡。颅内存在残留异物和骨碎片以及伤后和术后并发症与不存在这些情况相比意味着预后更差。
就预后而言,入院时的意识状态是最敏感的标准。预后还取决于脑损伤的程度,因为死亡率高的损伤主要是双侧半球损伤。关于生存,受伤至入院的时间以及颅内残留异物和骨碎片以及并发症的发生似乎也很重要。残留碎片的存在与感染的发生之间没有关系,这表明不必因残留碎片而再次手术。我们认为早期手术对治疗结果至关重要,尽管不必因残留碎片而再次手术。