Hautus Michael J, Lee Alan
Department of Psychology, University of Auckland, New Zealand.
Br J Math Stat Psychol. 2006 Nov;59(Pt 2):257-73. doi: 10.1348/000711005X65753.
The estimation of sensitivity and bias from data collected in a yes/no detection-theoretic experiment is complicated by the possibility of proportions of 0 or 1 appearing in the resulting contingency table. Inverse normal transforms of these probabilities result in mathematically intractable infinities. Typically, some transformation of the data must be applied prior to parameter estimation. Several transformations have been reviewed in the literature, in terms of both the bias and the variance of the estimates they produce. We propose three generalized transformations, which contain the two most reported transformations as special cases, and consider their performance in terms of the mean square error of the estimates they produce. Results indicate that the '1/N ' and the adaptive log-linear transformations outperform the others. Guidelines for the application of these transformations are presented.
在是/否检测理论实验中收集的数据中,由于列联表中可能出现0或1的比例,灵敏度和偏差的估计变得复杂。这些概率的逆正态变换会导致数学上难以处理的无穷大。通常,在参数估计之前必须对数据进行某种变换。文献中已经对几种变换进行了综述,涉及它们产生的估计的偏差和方差。我们提出了三种广义变换,其中包含了文献中报道最多的两种变换作为特殊情况,并根据它们产生的估计的均方误差来考虑它们的性能。结果表明,“1/N”变换和自适应对数线性变换的性能优于其他变换。本文还给出了这些变换的应用指南。