Schilling Keith E, Spooner Jean
Iowa Department of Natural Resources, Iowa Geological Survey, 109 Trowbridge Hall, Iowa City, IA 52242-1319, USA.
J Environ Qual. 2006 Oct 27;35(6):2132-45. doi: 10.2134/jeq2006.0157. Print 2006 Nov-Dec.
The Walnut Creek Watershed Monitoring Project was conducted from 1995 through 2005 to evaluate the response of stream nitrate concentrations to changing land use patterns in paired 5000-ha Iowa watersheds. A large portion of the Walnut Creek watershed is being converted from row crop agriculture to native prairie and savanna by the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service at the Neal Smith National Wildlife Refuge (NSNWR). Before restoration, land use in both Walnut Creek (treatment) and Squaw Creek (control) watersheds consisted of 70% row crops. Between 1990 and 2005, row crop area decreased 25.4% in Walnut Creek due to prairie restoration but increased 9.2% in Squaw Creek due to Conservation Reserve Program (CRP) grassland conversion back to row crop. Nitrate concentrations ranged between <0.5 to 14 mg L(-1) at the Walnut Creek outlet and 2.1 to 15 mg L(-1) at the downstream Squaw Creek outlet. Nitrate concentrations decreased 1.2 mg L(-1) over 10 yr in the Walnut Creek watershed but increased 1.9 mg L(-1) over 10 yr in Squaw Creek. Changes in nitrate were easier to detect and more pronounced in monitored subbasins, decreasing 1.2 to 3.4 mg L(-1) in three Walnut Creek subbasins, but increasing up to 8.0 and 11.6 mg L(-1) in 10 yr in two Squaw Creek subbasins. Converting row crop lands to grass reduced stream nitrate levels over time in Walnut Creek, but stream nitrate rapidly increased in Squaw Creek when CRP grasslands were converted back to row crop. Study results highlight the close association of stream nitrate to land use change and emphasize that grasslands or other perennial vegetation placed in agricultural settings should be part of a long-term solution to water quality problems.
核桃溪流域监测项目于1995年至2005年开展,旨在评估爱荷华州成对的5000公顷流域中溪流硝酸盐浓度对土地利用模式变化的响应。美国鱼类和野生动物管理局在尼尔·史密斯国家野生动物保护区(NSNWR)将核桃溪流域的大部分土地从行栽作物农业转变为原生草原和稀树草原。在恢复之前,核桃溪(处理区)和斯夸溪(对照区)流域的土地利用均有70%为行栽作物。1990年至2005年间,由于草原恢复,核桃溪的行栽作物面积减少了25.4%,而由于保护储备计划(CRP)草地转变为行栽作物,斯夸溪的行栽作物面积增加了9.2%。核桃溪出水口的硝酸盐浓度范围为<0.5至14毫克/升,下游斯夸溪出水口的硝酸盐浓度范围为2.1至15毫克/升。核桃溪流域的硝酸盐浓度在10年内下降了1.2毫克/升,但斯夸溪在10年内增加了1.9毫克/升。硝酸盐的变化在监测的子流域中更容易检测到且更为明显,在核桃溪的三个子流域中减少了1.2至3.4毫克/升,但在斯夸溪的两个子流域中10年内增加了高达8.0和11.6毫克/升。随着时间的推移,将行栽作物土地转变为草地降低了核桃溪的溪流硝酸盐水平,但当CRP草地转变回行栽作物时,斯夸溪的溪流硝酸盐迅速增加。研究结果突出了溪流硝酸盐与土地利用变化的紧密关联,并强调在农业环境中种植草地或其他多年生植被应成为解决水质问题长期方案的一部分。