Averbuch Diana, Schapiro Jonathan M, Lanier E Randall, Gradstein Serge, Gottesman Giora, Kedem Eynat, Einhorn Menachem, Grisaru-Soen Galia, Ofir Michal, Engelhard Dan, Grossman Zehava
Hadassah University Medical Center, Jerusalem, Israel.
Pediatr Infect Dis J. 2006 Nov;25(11):1049-56. doi: 10.1097/01.inf.0000243211.36690.d5.
We retrospectively studied the effect of the lamivudine-induced reverse transcription mutation M184V on selection of thymidine analog mutations (TAMs) in HIV subtype C-infected children and on clinical outcome.
We genotyped 135 blood samples from 55 children. TAMs accumulation, viral load and clinical outcome were compared in children maintained on zidovudine/stavudine + lamivudine + protease inhibitor/nonnucleoside reverse transcriptase inhibitor (PI/NNRTI) despite loss of viral suppression and in children treated with, or switched to, other nucleoside reverse transcriptase inhibitors (NRTIs). Drug susceptibility and replication capacity of selected samples were measured.
M184V developed in 18 of 22 of children who had received only zidovudine/stavudine + lamivudine + PI/NNRTI during a mean of 23.2 +/- 3.2 months versus in 3 of 14 children treated with other drugs and/or having multiple regimen changes (P = 0.001). TAMs appeared, respectively, in 2 of 22 versus 12 of 14 (P < 0.0001). The 2 groups did not differ significantly in baseline HIV-RNA or CD4 count, sampling time, and follow-up period. In M184V-containing samples, we found large reductions in susceptibility to lamivudine and emtricitabine but not to other NRTIs. When T215Y was present without M184V, susceptibility to zidovudine was reduced 8-fold. When both M184V + T215Y occurred, susceptibility to zidovudine was substantially increased. Average inhibition concentration 50 values were similar to those documented in the Stanford database for subtype B HIV with these mutation patterns.
Maintaining a thymidine analog + lamivudine-based regimen reduced accumulation of TAMs and increased zidovudine susceptibility. This is likely the result of an increased susceptibility to thymidine analog (zidovudine) in the context of M184V documented here for the first time in subtype C-infected children. This retrospective study supports the strategy of maintaining lamivudine-containing therapy in subtype C-infected children. This strategy may be beneficially applied in the treatment of children in Africa, where thymidine analog + lamivudine-based regimen became available recently but further options are limited.
我们回顾性研究了拉米夫定诱导的逆转录突变M184V对C型HIV感染儿童中胸苷类似物突变(TAMs)选择及临床结局的影响。
我们对55名儿童的135份血样进行了基因分型。比较了在病毒抑制丧失后仍接受齐多夫定/司他夫定+拉米夫定+蛋白酶抑制剂/非核苷类逆转录酶抑制剂(PI/NNRTI)治疗的儿童以及接受其他核苷类逆转录酶抑制剂(NRTIs)治疗或转用其他NRTIs的儿童的TAMs积累、病毒载量和临床结局。测定了所选样本的药物敏感性和复制能力。
在平均23.2±3.2个月期间仅接受齐多夫定/司他夫定+拉米夫定+PI/NNRTI治疗的22名儿童中有18名出现了M184V,而在接受其他药物治疗和/或有多种治疗方案变更的14名儿童中有3名出现了M184V(P = 0.001)。TAMs分别在22名儿童中的2名和14名儿童中的12名中出现(P < 0.0001)。两组在基线HIV-RNA或CD4计数、采样时间和随访期方面无显著差异。在含有M184V的样本中,我们发现对拉米夫定和恩曲他滨的敏感性大幅降低,但对其他NRTIs的敏感性未降低。当T215Y单独出现而无M184V时,对齐多夫定的敏感性降低8倍。当M184V和T215Y同时出现时,对齐多夫定的敏感性大幅增加。半数平均抑制浓度值与斯坦福数据库中记录的具有这些突变模式的B型HIV相似。
维持基于胸苷类似物+拉米夫定的治疗方案可减少TAMs的积累并增加对齐多夫定的敏感性。这可能是由于在此首次记录的C型感染儿童中,在M184V背景下对胸苷类似物(齐多夫定)的敏感性增加所致。这项回顾性研究支持在C型感染儿童中维持含拉米夫定治疗的策略。该策略可能有益地应用于非洲儿童的治疗,在那里基于胸苷类似物+拉米夫定的治疗方案最近才可用,但其他选择有限。