Shultz Mary
Library of the Health Sciences-Urbana, University of Illinois at Chicago, 102 Medical Sciences Building, 506 South Mathews, Urbana, Illinois 61801, USA.
J Med Libr Assoc. 2006 Oct;94(4):410-4.
Given the common use of acronyms and initialisms in the health sciences, searchers may be entering these abbreviated terms rather than full phrases when searching online systems. The purpose of this study is to evaluate how various MEDLINE Medical Subject Headings (MeSH) interfaces map acronyms and initialisms to the MeSH vocabulary.
The interfaces used in this study were: the PubMed MeSH database, the PubMed Automatic Term Mapping feature, the NLM Gateway Term Finder, and Ovid MEDLINE. Acronyms and initialisms were randomly selected from 2 print sources. The test data set included 415 randomly selected acronyms and initialisms whose related meanings were found to be MeSH terms. Each acronym and initialism was entered into each MEDLINE MeSH interface to determine if it mapped to the corresponding MeSH term. Separately, 46 commonly used acronyms and initialisms were tested.
While performance differed widely, the success rates were low across all interfaces for the randomly selected terms. The common acronyms and initialisms tested at higher success rates across the interfaces, but the differences between the interfaces remained.
Online interfaces do not always map medical acronyms and initialisms to their corresponding MeSH phrases. This may lead to inaccurate results and missed information if acronyms and initialisms are used in search strategies.
鉴于首字母缩略词和首字母缩合词在健康科学领域的广泛使用,搜索者在在线系统中进行搜索时可能输入的是这些缩写词而非完整短语。本研究的目的是评估各种MEDLINE医学主题词(MeSH)界面如何将首字母缩略词和首字母缩合词映射到MeSH词汇表。
本研究中使用的界面有:PubMed MeSH数据库、PubMed自动术语映射功能、NLM网关术语查找器和Ovid MEDLINE。首字母缩略词和首字母缩合词从2种印刷来源中随机选取。测试数据集包括415个随机选取的首字母缩略词和首字母缩合词,其相关含义被发现是MeSH术语。每个首字母缩略词和首字母缩合词都输入到每个MEDLINE MeSH界面中,以确定它是否映射到相应的MeSH术语。另外,对46个常用的首字母缩略词和首字母缩合词进行了测试。
虽然各界面的表现差异很大,但对于随机选取的术语,所有界面的成功率都很低。所测试的常用首字母缩略词和首字母缩合词在各界面的成功率较高,但各界面之间的差异仍然存在。
在线界面并不总是将医学首字母缩略词和首字母缩合词映射到其相应的MeSH短语。如果在搜索策略中使用首字母缩略词和首字母缩合词,这可能会导致结果不准确和信息遗漏。