Maynou C, Ménager S, Senneville E, Bocquet D, Mestdagh H
Service de Chirurgie Orthopédique A, Hôpital Salengro, CHRU de Lille, 2 avenue Oscar-Lambret, 59037 Lille Cedex.
Rev Chir Orthop Reparatrice Appar Mot. 2006 Oct;92(6):567-74. doi: 10.1016/s0035-1040(06)75914-1.
Infection is a rare complication of shoulder arthroplasty. Various therapeutic solutions have been proposed: antibiotics alone, one-stage or two-stage reimplantation, surgical or arthroscopic cleaning without prosthesis removal, scapulohumeral arthrodesis or simple arthroscopic resection. We evaluated the mid-term clinical outcome after resection arthroplasty for the treatment of infected shoulder arthroplasty.
The series included ten infected arthroplasties in ten patients. Mean duration of implantation was two years seven months (range nine months to five years). Bacteriological diagnosis was established from intraoperative articular samples or systematic samples taken during surgical revision procedures: meti-S Staphylococcus aureus strains (n=4), coagulase-negative Staphylococcus (n=5 including three S. epidermidis) Streptococcus mitis (n=1) and Citrobacter koseri (n=1). The mean Constant score before revision was 58 (range 23-77). Subjective patient satisfaction before surgical revision was rated good in six cases, fair in one and poor in three. Surgery associated removal of the implant, complete resection of the cement, resection of the fistular tracts, wide debridement of infected tissues and total synovectomy.
Patients were seen at an average follow-up of three years eight months. The objective functional outcome measured with the Constant score was only fair, 28 points (range 20.6-36), and corresponded to a loss of 29 points compared with the preoperative score. This was explained mainly by lower scores for joint motion, function and muscle force but with persistently satisfactory scores for pain. All patients remained pain-free (daytime and nighttime). Patient satisfaction was rated good for two, fair for five and mediocre for three. Clinical and biological proof of eradicated infection was obtained in all patients.
Infection remains a serious devastating problem for shoulder arthroplasty with an important functional impact. Resection only has a modest clinical effect. Precise identification of the causal germ with institution of adapted antibiotic therapy is required for eradication of the infection. Early diagnosis is probably the most important parameter affecting clinical outcome and surgical options. Functional results after resection arthroplasty are modest. This procedure should be reserved for patients with reduced functional demands. Improved management of the infectious load and reduction of diagnostic delay should help improve functional outcome and favor use of stow-stage procedures for reinsertion.
感染是肩关节置换术的一种罕见并发症。已提出了各种治疗方案:单独使用抗生素、一期或二期再植入、不取出假体的手术或关节镜清理、肩胛肱骨关节固定术或单纯关节镜下切除术。我们评估了切除关节成形术治疗感染性肩关节置换术后的中期临床结果。
该系列包括10例患者的10例感染性关节成形术。平均植入时间为2年7个月(范围为9个月至5年)。通过术中关节样本或手术翻修过程中采集的系统性样本进行细菌学诊断:耐甲氧西林金黄色葡萄球菌菌株(n = 4)、凝固酶阴性葡萄球菌(n = 5,包括3例表皮葡萄球菌)、缓症链球菌(n = 1)和科氏柠檬酸杆菌(n = 1)。翻修前的平均Constant评分是58分(范围为23 - 77分)。手术翻修前患者主观满意度为6例良好、1例一般、3例较差。手术包括取出植入物、彻底切除骨水泥、切除瘘管、广泛清创感染组织和全滑膜切除术。
患者平均随访3年8个月。用Constant评分衡量的客观功能结果仅为一般,28分(范围为20.6 - 36分),与术前评分相比下降了29分。这主要是由于关节活动度、功能和肌肉力量评分较低,但疼痛评分一直令人满意。所有患者均无疼痛(白天和夜间)。患者满意度为2例良好、5例一般、3例中等。所有患者均获得感染根除的临床和生物学证据。
感染仍然是肩关节置换术的一个严重破坏性问题,对功能有重要影响。单纯切除的临床效果一般。为根除感染,需要准确识别致病微生物并采用适当的抗生素治疗。早期诊断可能是影响临床结果和手术选择的最重要因素。切除关节成形术后的功能结果一般。该手术应仅用于功能需求较低的患者。改善感染负荷的管理并减少诊断延迟应有助于改善功能结果,并有利于采用二期手术进行再植入。