Dorr David A, Jones Spencer S, Wilcox Adam
Department of Medical Informatics and Clinical Epidemiology, Oregon Health and Science University, Portland, OR, USA.
J Biomed Inform. 2007 Jun;40(3):282-7. doi: 10.1016/j.jbi.2006.10.001. Epub 2006 Oct 10.
Clinical information systems (CIS) can affect the quality of patient care. In this paper, we focus on CIS use in the collaborative treatment of chronic diseases. We have developed a framework to determine which CIS functions have general usefulness for improving patient outcomes.
We reviewed the use of clinical information systems within a collaborative care environment, identifying CIS functions important in chronic disease care. We grouped the functions into categories of access, best practices, and communication (ABC). Three independent raters selected the most important collaborative care related functions from the HL7 Electronic Health Record Systems functional model, and mapped the HL7 functions against the ABC categories. We then built a model of CIS use and tested it on data from a cohort of patients with chronic illnesses.
Of the 133 HL7 elements in the ABC model, 60 (45%) were ranked as important for collaborative care by two reviewers. Agreement was moderate for importance (kappa=.20) but high for ABC categorization (kappa=.67). In our data tests, for the 1105 patients, access 4.4+/-6.5, best practices 0.8+/-1.6, and communication 2.9+/-4.5. CIS functions were used per episode of care. We were able to identify several key functions that may affect patient care. For example, certain CIS functions related to best practices were associated with higher clinician adherence to testing guidelines.
This framework may be useful to assess and compare CIS systems for collaborative care. Future refinements of the model are discussed.
临床信息系统(CIS)会影响患者护理质量。在本文中,我们聚焦于CIS在慢性病协同治疗中的应用。我们开发了一个框架,以确定哪些CIS功能对改善患者预后具有普遍实用性。
我们回顾了协同护理环境中临床信息系统的使用情况,确定了在慢性病护理中重要的CIS功能。我们将这些功能分为访问、最佳实践和沟通(ABC)三类。三名独立评估者从HL7电子健康记录系统功能模型中选出与协同护理最相关的功能,并将HL7功能与ABC类别进行映射。然后我们构建了一个CIS使用模型,并在一组慢性病患者的数据上进行了测试。
在ABC模型的133个HL7元素中,有60个(45%)被两位评估者列为对协同护理重要的元素。重要性方面的一致性为中等(kappa = 0.20),但ABC分类方面的一致性较高(kappa = 0.67)。在我们的数据测试中,对于1105名患者,访问功能得分为4.4±6.5,最佳实践功能得分为0.8±1.6,沟通功能得分为2.9±4.5。每次护理都会使用CIS功能。我们能够识别出一些可能影响患者护理的关键功能。例如,某些与最佳实践相关的CIS功能与临床医生对检测指南的更高依从性相关。
该框架可能有助于评估和比较用于协同护理的CIS系统。文中还讨论了该模型未来的改进方向。