Harris Grant T, Parle Daniel, Gagné Joseph
Research Department, Penetanguishene Mental Health Centre, 500 Church St., Penetanguishene, ON L9M 1G3, Canada.
J Behav Health Serv Res. 2007 Jan;34(1):43-55. doi: 10.1007/s11414-006-9043-1. Epub 2006 Dec 19.
A total ban on all tobacco products was implemented in a diverse psychiatric institution. A post hoc evaluation examined the effect of the ban on long-term patients by comparing their characteristics the year before the ban to the year after. Several variables measuring physical health, psychiatric symptomatology, feelings of well-being, and interpersonal conflict were coded with very high reliability from health records. For the majority of patients who were in the maximum security forensic division, the tobacco ban was associated with almost no detectable ill effects with some clear benefits. Among the remainder of the long-term patients, the ban might have been associated with a temporary increase in physical aggression towards staff members. It was concluded that successful implementation, and the avoidance of ill effects, depended entirely on the success staff members had in actually preventing patient access to tobacco.
一家多元化的精神病院实施了全面禁止所有烟草产品的规定。事后评估通过比较禁令实施前一年和实施后一年长期住院患者的特征,研究了禁令对他们的影响。从健康记录中对几个衡量身体健康、精神症状、幸福感和人际冲突的变量进行了非常可靠的编码。对于大多数处于最高安全级别的法医部门的患者来说,烟草禁令几乎没有可察觉的不良影响,还有一些明显的益处。在其余的长期住院患者中,禁令可能与对工作人员身体攻击行为的暂时增加有关。得出的结论是,成功实施并避免不良影响完全取决于工作人员在实际防止患者获得烟草方面的成功程度。