Kaissi Amer
From the Department of Health Care Administration, Trinity University, San Antonio, TX 78212, USA.
Health Care Manag (Frederick). 2006 Oct-Dec;25(4):292-305. doi: 10.1097/00126450-200610000-00002.
Progress in patient safety, or lack thereof, is a cause for great concern. In this article, we argue that the patient safety movement has failed to reach its goals of eradicating or, at least, significantly reducing errors because of an inappropriate focus on provider and patient-level factors with no real attention to the organizational factors that affect patient safety. We describe an organizational approach to patient safety using different organizational theory perspectives and make several propositions to push patient safety research and practice in a direction that is more likely to improve care processes and outcomes. From a Contingency Theory perspective, we suggest that health care organizations, in general, operate under a misfit between contingencies and structures. This misfit is mainly due to lack of flexibility, cost containment, and lack of regulations, thus explaining the high level of errors committed in these organizations. From an organizational culture perspective, we argue that health care organizations must change their assumptions, beliefs, values, and artifacts to change their culture from a culture of blame to a culture of safety and thus reduce medical errors. From an organizational learning perspective, we discuss how reporting, analyzing, and acting on error information can result in reduced errors in health care organizations.
患者安全方面的进展,或缺乏进展,令人深感忧虑。在本文中,我们认为患者安全运动未能实现其根除或至少显著减少错误的目标,原因在于不恰当地将重点放在医疗服务提供者和患者层面的因素上,而未真正关注影响患者安全的组织因素。我们运用不同的组织理论视角描述一种患者安全的组织方法,并提出若干建议,以推动患者安全研究与实践朝着更有可能改善医疗流程和结果的方向发展。从权变理论的角度来看,我们认为一般而言,医疗保健组织在权变因素与结构之间存在不匹配的情况下运作。这种不匹配主要是由于缺乏灵活性、成本控制和缺乏监管,从而解释了这些组织中出现的高错误率。从组织文化的角度来看,我们认为医疗保健组织必须改变其假设、信念、价值观和人工制品,以将其文化从责备文化转变为安全文化,从而减少医疗错误。从组织学习的角度来看,我们讨论如何对错误信息进行报告、分析并采取行动,从而减少医疗保健组织中的错误。