Thie Joseph A, Hubner Karl F, Isidoro Francis P, Smith Gary T
Graduate School of Medicine, University of Tennessee Medical Center, Knoxville, Tennessee, USA.
Mol Imaging Biol. 2007 Mar-Apr;9(2):91-8. doi: 10.1007/s11307-006-0068-x.
Known errors in the standardized uptake value (SUV) caused by variations in subject weights W encountered can be corrected by lean body mass or body surface area (bsa) algorithms replacing W in calculations. However this is infrequently done. The aims of the work here are: quantify sensitivity to W, encourage SUV correction with an approach minimally differing from tradition, and show what improvements in the SUV coefficient of variation (cv) for a population can be expected.
Selected for analyses were 2-deoxy-2-[F-18]fluoro-D-glucose (FDG) SUV data from positron emission tomography (PET) and PET/computed tomography (CT) scans at the University of Tennessee as well as from the literature. A weight sensitivity index was defined as -n=slope of ln(SUV/W) vs. lnW. The portion of the SUV variability due to this trend is removed by using the defined [formula: see text], or a virtually equal SUVm using [formula: see text], with Q and ID being tissue specific-activity and injected dose. [formula: see text] measures performance. Adapting to animal studies' tradition, [formula: see text] is preferred over the conventional [formula: see text].
For FDG in adults [formula: see text] from averaging over most tissues. In children, however, [formula: see text]. Tissues have the same index if their influx constants are independent of W. Suggested, therefore, is a very simplified [formula: see text], which is dimensionless and keeps the same population averages as traditional SUVs. It achieves [formula: see text]. Hence, for cv's of SUVs below approximately 1/3 improvements over tradition are possible, leading to F's<0.95. Accounting additionally for height, as in SUVbsa, gives very little improvement over the simplified approach here and gives essentially the same F's as SUVm.
Introduced here is a weight index useful in reducing variability and further understanding the SUV. Addressing weight sensitivity is appropriate where the cv of the SUVs is below about 1/3. Proposed is the very simple approach of using an average of an adult patient's weight and approximately 70 kg for FDG SUV calculations. Unlike other approaches the dimensionless population average of SUVms is unchanged from tradition.
已知标准化摄取值(SUV)因受检者体重(W)变化而产生的误差,可通过在计算中用瘦体重或体表面积(bsa)算法替代W来校正。然而,这种做法并不常见。本文的工作目的是:量化对W的敏感性,以一种与传统方法差异最小的方式鼓励对SUV进行校正,并展示对一组人群而言,SUV变异系数(cv)有望得到哪些改善。
选取了田纳西大学正电子发射断层扫描(PET)及PET/计算机断层扫描(CT)的2-脱氧-2-[F-18]氟-D-葡萄糖(FDG)SUV数据以及文献中的数据进行分析。体重敏感性指数定义为ln(SUV/W)对lnW的斜率-n。通过使用定义的[公式:见原文],或使用[公式:见原文]得到的几乎相等的SUVm,去除因该趋势导致的SUV变异性部分,其中Q和ID分别为组织比活度和注射剂量。[公式:见原文]衡量性能。为适应动物研究传统,[公式:见原文]比传统的[公式:见原文]更受青睐。
对于成年人的FDG,大多数组织平均[公式:见原文]。然而,在儿童中,[公式:见原文]。如果组织的流入常数与W无关,则组织具有相同的指数。因此,建议采用一种非常简化的[公式:见原文],它是无量纲的,并且与传统SUV保持相同的总体平均值。它实现了[公式:见原文]。因此,对于SUV的cv低于约1/3的情况,相对于传统方法有可能得到改善,使得F<0.95。如在SUVbsa中那样额外考虑身高,相对于本文的简化方法几乎没有改进,并且得到的F与SUVm基本相同。
本文引入了一个有助于减少变异性并进一步理解SUV的体重指数。在SUV的cv低于约1/3的情况下,解决体重敏感性问题是合适的。建议采用一种非常简单的方法,即在FDG SUV计算中使用成年患者体重与约70 kg的平均值。与其他方法不同,SUVm的无量纲总体平均值与传统方法相同。