Sachse S, Saracino M, von Suchodoletz W
Institut für Kinder- und Jugendpsychiatrie und Psychotherapie, Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität München, Germany.
Klin Padiatr. 2007 Jan-Feb;219(1):17-22. doi: 10.1055/s-2005-836842.
Early identification of developmental language disorders is a precondition for early intervention and therefore of high clinical relevance. The ELFRA-1 was constructed to identify children at risk for language disorders in the context of the routine examination of children at the age of 12 months. The aim of the study was to determine the predictive validity of this screening tool.
121 parents completed the questionnaire for their 12 months old children. One year later the language development was assessed by means of the ELFRA-2, the German version of the CDI for two year old children.
63% of the children were correctly classified. The sensitivity amounted to 52% and the specificity to 65%. The RATZ-index (relative improvement of the hit rate in comparison to the random hit rate) was 23%, which has to be considered as unsatisfying. Improvement of language abilities were less likely in boys compared to girls and in cases of low educational background of the mother.
The prognostic validity of the ELFRA-1 is insufficient and too low to identify children at risk for later language impairment. The screening overlooked too many late talkers and classified too many normally developed children as language impaired. The ELFRA-1 can not be recommended as a useful method for the early identification of language impaired children at the age of 12 months.
早期识别发育性语言障碍是早期干预的前提条件,因此具有高度的临床相关性。ELFRA-1旨在在对12个月大儿童进行常规检查的背景下识别有语言障碍风险的儿童。本研究的目的是确定这种筛查工具的预测效度。
121名家长为他们12个月大的孩子填写了问卷。一年后,通过ELFRA-2(针对两岁儿童的德语版CDI)对语言发育进行评估。
63%的儿童被正确分类。敏感性为52%,特异性为65%。RATZ指数(与随机命中率相比命中率的相对提高)为23%,这被认为是不令人满意的。与女孩相比,男孩以及母亲教育背景较低的情况下,语言能力提高的可能性较小。
ELFRA-1的预后效度不足,过低以至于无法识别有后期语言障碍风险的儿童。该筛查遗漏了太多说话晚的儿童,并且将太多正常发育的儿童归类为语言障碍。ELFRA-1不能被推荐作为在12个月大时早期识别语言障碍儿童的有用方法。