Boor K, Scheele F, van der Vleuten C P M, Scherpbier A J J A, Teunissen P W, Sijtsma K
Department of Medical Education, Sint Lucas Andreas Hospital, Amsterdam, The Netherlands.
Med Educ. 2007 Jan;41(1):92-9. doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2929.2006.02651.x.
The clinical learning environment is an influential factor in work-based learning. Evaluation of this environment gives insight into the educational functioning of clinical departments. The Postgraduate Hospital Educational Environment Measure (PHEEM) is an evaluation tool consisting of a validated questionnaire with 3 subscales. In this paper we further investigate the psychometric properties of the PHEEM. We set out to validate the 3 subscales and test the reliability of the PHEEM for both clerks (clinical medical students) and registrars (specialists in training).
Clerks and registrars from different hospitals and specialties filled out the PHEEM. To investigate the construct validity of the 3 subscales, we used an exploratory factor analysis followed by varimax rotation, and a cluster analysis known as Mokken scale analysis. We estimated the reliability of the questionnaire by means of variance components according to generalisability theory.
A total of 256 clerks and 339 registrars filled out the questionnaire. The exploratory factor analysis plus varimax rotation suggested a 1-dimensional scale. The Mokken scale analysis confirmed this result. The reliability analysis showed a reliable outcome for 1 department with 14 clerks or 11 registrars. For multiple departments 3 respondents combined with 10 departments provide a reliable outcome for both groups.
The PHEEM is a questionnaire measuring 1 dimension instead of the hypothesised 3 dimensions. The sample size required to achieve a reliable outcome is feasible. The instrument can be used to evaluate both single and multiple departments for both clerks and registrars.
临床学习环境是基于工作的学习中的一个影响因素。对该环境的评估有助于深入了解临床科室的教育功能。研究生医院教育环境测量工具(PHEEM)是一种评估工具,由一份经过验证的问卷组成,包含3个分量表。在本文中,我们进一步研究PHEEM的心理测量特性。我们着手验证这3个分量表,并测试PHEEM对实习医生(临床医学生)和住院医生(专科培训医生)的可靠性。
来自不同医院和专业的实习医生和住院医生填写了PHEEM。为了研究这3个分量表的结构效度,我们采用了探索性因素分析并进行方差最大化旋转,以及一种称为莫肯量表分析的聚类分析。我们根据概化理论通过方差成分估计问卷的可靠性。
共有256名实习医生和339名住院医生填写了问卷。探索性因素分析加方差最大化旋转表明是一个单维度量表。莫肯量表分析证实了这一结果。可靠性分析表明,对于1个有14名实习医生或11名住院医生的科室,结果是可靠的。对于多个科室,3名受访者与10个科室相结合,两组的结果都是可靠的。
PHEEM是一个测量单维度而非假设的3个维度的问卷。获得可靠结果所需的样本量是可行的。该工具可用于评估实习医生和住院医生的单个科室和多个科室。