Yilmaz Nilufer Demiral, Velipasaoglu Serpil, Ozan Sema, Basusta Bilge Uzun, Midik Ozlem, Mamakli Sumer, Karaoglu Nazan, Tengiz Funda, Durak Halil İbrahim, Sahin Hatice
Department of Medical Education, Faculty of Medicine, Ege University, Izmir, Turkey.
Department of Medical Education, Faculty of Medicine, Dokuz Eylül University, Izmir, Turkey.
Med Educ Online. 2016 Sep 16;21:30846. doi: 10.3402/meo.v21.30846. eCollection 2016.
The relationship between students and instructors is of crucial importance for the development of a positive learning climate. Learning climate is a multifaceted concept, and its measurement is a complicated process. The aim of this cross-sectional study was to determine medical students' perceptions about the clinical learning climate and to investigate differences in their perceptions in terms of various variables.
Medical students studying at six medical schools in Turkey were recruited for the study. All students who completed clinical rotations, which lasted for 3 or more weeks, were included in the study (n=3,097). Data were collected using the Clinical Learning Climate Scale (CLCS). The CLCS (36 items) includes three subscales: clinical environment, emotion, and motivation. Each item is scored using a 5-point Likert scale (1: strongly disagree to 5: strongly agree).
The response rate for the trainees was 69.67% (n=1,519), and for the interns it was 51.47% (n=917). The mean total CLCS score was 117.20±17.19. The rotation during which the clinical learning climate was perceived most favorably was the Physical Therapy and Rehabilitation rotation (mean score: 137.77). The most negatively perceived rotation was the General Internal Medicine rotation (mean score: 104.31). There were significant differences between mean total scores in terms of trainee/intern characteristics, internal medicine/surgical medicine rotations, and perception of success.
The results of this study drew attention to certain aspects of the clinical learning climate in medical schools. Clinical teacher/instructor/supervisor, clinical training programs, students' interactions in clinical settings, self-realization, mood, students' intrinsic motivation, and institutional commitment are important components of the clinical learning climate. For this reason, the aforementioned components should be taken into consideration in studies aiming to improve clinical learning climate.
学生与教师之间的关系对于营造积极的学习氛围至关重要。学习氛围是一个多方面的概念,其测量是一个复杂的过程。这项横断面研究的目的是确定医学生对临床学习氛围的看法,并调查他们在各种变量方面看法的差异。
招募了在土耳其六所医学院学习的医学生参与该研究。所有完成为期3周或更长时间临床轮转的学生都纳入了研究(n = 3097)。使用临床学习氛围量表(CLCS)收集数据。CLCS(36个项目)包括三个子量表:临床环境、情感和动机。每个项目使用5点李克特量表评分(1:强烈不同意至5:强烈同意)。
实习生的回复率为69.67%(n = 1519),住院医师的回复率为51.47%(n = 917)。CLCS总平均分为117.20±17.19。临床学习氛围被认为最有利的轮转是物理治疗与康复轮转(平均得分:137.77)。负面看法最多的轮转是普通内科轮转(平均得分:104.31)。在实习生/住院医师特征、内科/外科轮转以及对成功的看法方面,总平均分存在显著差异。
本研究结果提请人们关注医学院临床学习氛围的某些方面。临床教师/指导教师/督导、临床培训项目、学生在临床环境中的互动、自我实现、情绪、学生的内在动机以及机构承诺是临床学习氛围的重要组成部分。因此,在旨在改善临床学习氛围的研究中应考虑上述组成部分。