Mihai Adriana, Damsa Cristian, Allen Michael, Baleydier Bertrand, Lazignac Coralie, Heinz Andreas
Department of Psychiatry, University of Medicine and Pharmacy, Tg Mures, Romania.
Addiction. 2007 Feb;102(2):226-31. doi: 10.1111/j.1360-0443.2006.01667.x.
The aim of this prospective randomized controlled study was to determine whether viewing videotape of themselves while experiencing delirium tremens (DT) reduces the relapse rate in alcohol-dependent patients. Our hypothesis about the efficacy of videotapes exposure to DT is consistent with a cognitive behavior model.
Sixty patients with DT and a minimum of 3 years of severe alcohol dependence [Diagnostic and Statistical Manual version IV (DSM-IV criteria] were included in this study. Patients were videotaped during the acute phase of DT and randomized into two groups: group A patients received individual exposure to their videotape and an explanation of the symptoms by a psychiatrist; and control group B patients, who were without videotape experience. Both groups received the same treatment during the acute and the maintenance phases, without aversive therapy or psychotherapy. The two groups did not differ significantly in number of drinks per day prior to admission, age, marital status, social environment, education, professional and financial status or family psychiatric history.
An in-patient crisis unit for patients with alcohol dependence.
All patients were observed for 6 months during monthly visits. Outcomes included relapse, drinking days per week and number of drinks per drinking day. All patients and their families signed informed consent.
The patients with videotape experience had a significantly lower relapse rate after the first month (0% versus 20%), 2 months (13.33% versus 46.67%) and 3 months (26.67% versus 53.33%). Patients with videotape experience had less severe relapses and consumed fewer units of alcohol than controls.
Videotape exposure in delirium tremens is an original therapeutic method which seems to be effective in reducing relapse risk in patients with alcohol dependence.
这项前瞻性随机对照研究的目的是确定酒精依赖患者在经历震颤谵妄(DT)时观看自己的录像带是否能降低复发率。我们关于录像带暴露于DT疗效的假设与认知行为模型一致。
本研究纳入了60名患有DT且至少有3年严重酒精依赖[《精神疾病诊断与统计手册》第四版(DSM-IV标准)]的患者。在DT急性期对患者进行录像,并随机分为两组:A组患者单独观看自己的录像带,并由精神科医生对症状进行解释;对照组B患者没有录像带体验。两组在急性期和维持期接受相同的治疗,不进行厌恶疗法或心理治疗。两组在入院前每天饮酒量、年龄、婚姻状况、社会环境、教育程度、职业和财务状况或家族精神病史方面无显著差异。
一家收治酒精依赖患者的住院危机病房。
所有患者在每月就诊时观察6个月。结果包括复发、每周饮酒天数和每次饮酒日的饮酒量。所有患者及其家属均签署了知情同意书。
有录像带体验的患者在第一个月(0%对20%)、第二个月(13.33%对46.67%)和第三个月(26.67%对53.33%)后的复发率显著较低。有录像带体验的患者复发程度较轻,饮酒量比对照组少。
震颤谵妄时的录像带暴露是一种原始的治疗方法,似乎对降低酒精依赖患者的复发风险有效。