Lohiya Ghan-Shyam, Tan-Figueroa Lilia, Lohiya Piyush, Bui De
J Natl Med Assoc. 2006 Dec;98(12):2019-23.
In a developmental center, a preemployment chest x-ray was required for all job applicants. We scrutinized the pros and cons of this practice through a review of the medical literature and our experience, and discussion with our colleagues. We concluded that such chest x-ray caused unwarranted radiation exposure, did not produce compliance with the tuberculosis laws, gave a false sense of security regarding workers' compensation risk management, was contrary to established occupational medicine practice guidelines, and was unnecessary and wasteful. We discontinued such chest x-rays. The purpose of the pre-employment examination should remain narrowly job related. Even long-established procedures require periodic utilization review.
在一个发展中心,所有求职者都需要进行入职前胸部X光检查。我们通过查阅医学文献、结合自身经验并与同事讨论,仔细研究了这种做法的利弊。我们得出结论,这种胸部X光检查造成了不必要的辐射暴露,未能确保符合结核病防治法规,在工伤风险管理方面给人一种虚假的安全感,与既定的职业医学实践指南相悖,既无必要又浪费资源。我们停止了此类胸部X光检查。入职前检查的目的应严格限于与工作相关的方面。即使是长期沿用的程序也需要定期进行使用审查。