Chemical nature of stochastic generation of protein-based carbonyls: metal-catalyzed oxidation versus modification by products of lipid oxidation.

An assessment of 2,4-dinitrophenylhydrazine (DNPH)-detectable protein-based carbonyls is one of the most common assays used to quantify oxidative stress in vitro and in vivo. In this study, we compared, for the lipid-binding protein beta-lactoglobulin, the extent to which carbonyl reactivity could be introduced by adventitious metal-catalyzed oxidation (MCO) in the absence and presence of a polyunsaturated lipid or by treatment with various individual bifunctional lipid oxidation products capable of introducing carbonyls into proteins by adduction to nucleophilic side chains. With metal ions and either O2/reductant or H2O2 as the terminal oxidant, the maximal level of DNPH-detectable carbonyl generation obtainable in several hours was 0.1-0.2 mol carbonyl per mol protein monomer, with Cu(II) being more effective than Fe(II). Exposure instead to bifunctional lipoxidation-derived aldehydes (1-2 mM) generated in some cases in excess of 1 mol carbonyl per mol protein. The rank order of carbonyl incorporation reactivity was acrolein > 4-oxo-2-nonenal > 4-hydroxy-2-nonenal > 2,4-decadienal > malondialdehyde. Protein cross-linking ability followed a somewhat different rank order. Parallel studies on reductively methylated beta-lactoglobulin revealed that His and Cys residues are intrinsically more responsible than Lys residues for carbonyl appearance and that the availability of Lys residues accounts for the reduction of carbonyl content at later time (presumably reflecting cross-linking chemistry) that occurs for acrolein and 4-oxo-2-nonenal. Overall, these results suggest that DNPH reactivity observed physiologically on nonmetalloproteins may arise more from the attachment of lipid-derived products of oxidative stress than from adventitious MCO of side chains. Additional studies carried out to clarify the potential use of DNPH derivatization to tag peptide-based carbonyls for mass spectrometric analysis revealed that DNPH derivatization can reverse under the conditions used for proteolysis.