Yasunaga Hideo, Ide Hiroo, Imamura Tomoaki, Ohe Kazuhiko
Department of Planning, Information and Management, University of Tokyo Hospital.
Nihon Koshu Eisei Zasshi. 2006 Nov;53(11):818-30.
Contingent valuation method (CVM) can be applied to measure benefits of healthcare services. It is a technique for estimating subjects' willingness to pay (WTP) for a service under the scenario describing a virtual market with a questionnaire. In the present research, we outlined foreign studies and reviewed domestic studies on healthcare contingent valuation. A total of 14 papers from domestic literature (five English and nine Japanese articles) identified with mechanical search engines were verified for the following eight items: the method of the questionnaire; the information included in the virtual scenario; the question form for the willingness to pay; bias problems specific to CVM; validity/reliability, ex post/ex ante valuation, altruistic WTP, and non-health value. The following conclusions were drawn from the domestic studies: (1) several studies were short of sufficient information regarding the virtual scenario; (2) no research proved the existence of bias and the ways of coping with it; (3) tests for reliability were not carried out, although some kind of validity was verified; (4) all involved ex post user based evaluation; (5) neither altruistic WTP nor non-health value was examined. Taken the advantages of CVM into consideration, it should become a useful tool, complementing other economic evaluation techniques. Since its application has just begun in Japan, more emphasis needs to be given to practical issues so that healthcare workers will utilize CVM in a way that domestic studies in health economics will be activated.
条件价值评估法(CVM)可用于衡量医疗服务的效益。它是一种通过问卷调查在虚拟市场情景下估计受试者对某项服务的支付意愿(WTP)的技术。在本研究中,我们概述了国外研究并回顾了国内关于医疗条件价值评估的研究。通过机械搜索引擎从国内文献中筛选出的14篇论文(5篇英文和9篇日文文章)针对以下八项内容进行了核实:问卷方法;虚拟情景中包含的信息;支付意愿的问题形式;CVM特有的偏差问题;有效性/可靠性、事后/事前评估、利他性支付意愿和非健康价值。从国内研究中得出以下结论:(1)几项研究缺乏关于虚拟情景的足够信息;(2)没有研究证明偏差的存在及其应对方法;(3)虽然验证了某种有效性,但未进行可靠性测试;(4)所有研究都涉及基于事后用户的评估;(5)既未考察利他性支付意愿,也未考察非健康价值。考虑到CVM的优点,它应成为一种有用的工具,补充其他经济评估技术。由于其在日本的应用刚刚起步,需要更加重视实际问题,以便医护人员能够以促进健康经济学国内研究活跃开展的方式使用CVM。