Jerjes W, El-Maaytah M, Swinson B, Upile T, Thompson G, Gittelmon S, Baldwin D, Hadi H, Vourvachis M, Abizadeh N, Al Khawalde M, Hopper C
University College London Hospitals London, England.
J Clin Dent. 2006;17(5):122-30.
The purpose of this study was to evaluate the relationship between preoperative panoramic radiological findings and postoperative inferior alveolar nerve paresthesia following third molar surgery, and to assess the surgical difficulty.
This retrospective study involved two groups of patients who were randomly selected. The first group presented with inferior alveolar nerve (IAN) paresthesia following surgery, and the second group presented with no complications, including IAN paresthesia. Radiological findings were collected from the panoramic radiographs of those patients and compared to postoperative paresthesia. The degree of surgical difficulty was also assessed radiographically.
The application of Chi-square testing on the numbness group and the control group, as well as the numbness group (two years postoperatively) and the control group, showed that parameters like type of impaction (fully impacted), depth of impaction (depth C), ramus/space (class 3), spatial relationship (distoangular and horizontal), number of roots (multiple and incomplete), shape of root (thick and incomplete), shape of the tip of root (curved and incomplete), and relation to IAN (touching, superimposed, or non-specific) are highly significant (p < 0.001) in predicting the incidence of temporary and permanent paresthesia. Logistic regression showed that a patient whose lower third molar is > or = 1 mm from IAC has a 98% probability of no numbness, while if the tooth is touching the IAC the probability of numbness between one week and < two years is 60%. Numbness probability of darkening of the root is 48% for > two years, deflection of the root has a 42% probability of > two years numbness, narrowing of the root has 87% of numbness between > one month and < two years, a dark and bifid root has a 97% of numbness between > six months and < two years, interruption of the IAC has a 54% chance of numbness between > one month and < two years, diversion of the canal has a 60% probability of > six months to > two years numbness, while narrowing of the canal has a probability of 100% of > six months to > two years numbness. By using logistic regression, cases that were recorded as "very difficult," according to the Pederson Difficulty Index, were more likely to develop permanent paresthesia (95%). The application of logistic regression on the radiological findings showed that we can use them in predicting nerve paresthesia following third molar surgery. A classification tree has been developed and found to be very accurate in predicting permanent numbness (95%) and no numbness (100%) in third molar surgery depending on the radiological findings.
Surgical difficulty of impacted third molars may be assessed radiographically through seven factors, including spatial relationship, depth of impaction, ramus relationship/space available, type of impaction, number and shape of roots, shape of the tip of the root, and relation of the root to the inferior alveolar nerve. The application of logistic regression on the radiological findings showed that we could use them in predicting nerve paresthesia following third molar surgery. By developing a classification tree, it is easier to predict the possibility of temporary or permanent paresthesia. A full collaboration between clinicians and radiologists may help to uncover more parameters that can lead to a more accurate prediction of temporary and permanent paresthesia.
本研究旨在评估第三磨牙手术后术前全景放射学检查结果与术后下牙槽神经感觉异常之间的关系,并评估手术难度。
本回顾性研究涉及两组随机选择的患者。第一组患者术后出现下牙槽神经(IAN)感觉异常,第二组患者无并发症,包括IAN感觉异常。从这些患者的全景X线片中收集放射学检查结果,并与术后感觉异常情况进行比较。还通过影像学评估手术难度。
对麻木组与对照组,以及麻木组(术后两年)与对照组进行卡方检验,结果显示阻生类型(完全阻生)、阻生深度(C类深度)、升支/间隙(3类)、空间关系(远中倾斜和水平)、牙根数量(多个和不完全)、牙根形状(粗大和不完全)、根尖形状(弯曲和不完全)以及与IAN的关系(接触、重叠或不明确)等参数在预测暂时性和永久性感觉异常的发生率方面具有高度显著性(p < 0.001)。逻辑回归分析显示,下颌第三磨牙距下牙槽神经管(IAC)≥1mm的患者无麻木感的概率为98%,而如果牙齿接触IAC,1周内至<2年出现麻木感的概率为60%。牙根变黑超过2年出现麻木感的概率为48%,牙根弯曲超过2年出现麻木感的概率为42%,牙根变窄在>1个月至<2年出现麻木感的概率为87%,牙根变黑且分叉在>6个月至<2年出现麻木感的概率为97%,IAC中断在>1个月至<2年出现麻木感的概率为54%,根管偏移在>6个月至>2年出现麻木感的概率为60%,而根管变窄在>6个月至>2年出现麻木感的概率为100%。根据佩德森难度指数记录为“非常困难”的病例,通过逻辑回归分析显示更有可能出现永久性感觉异常(95%)。对放射学检查结果进行逻辑回归分析表明,我们可以利用这些结果预测第三磨牙手术后的神经感觉异常。已开发出一种分类树,发现其在根据放射学检查结果预测第三磨牙手术中的永久性麻木(95%)和无麻木(100%)方面非常准确。
可以通过七个因素,包括空间关系、阻生深度、升支关系/可用间隙、阻生类型、牙根数量和形状、根尖形状以及牙根与下牙槽神经的关系,通过影像学评估阻生第三磨牙的手术难度。对放射学检查结果进行逻辑回归分析表明,我们可以利用这些结果预测第三磨牙手术后的神经感觉异常。通过开发分类树,更容易预测暂时性或永久性感觉异常的可能性。临床医生和放射科医生之间的充分合作可能有助于发现更多参数,从而更准确地预测暂时性和永久性感觉异常。