Pollard Richard J, Coyle Joseph P, Gilbert Richard L, Beck Janet E
Southeast Anesthesiology Consultants, North Carolina 28203, USA.
Anesthesiology. 2007 Feb;106(2):269-74. doi: 10.1097/00000542-200702000-00014.
Intraoperative awareness in patients undergoing general anesthesia is an infrequent but well-described adverse outcome. The reported incidence of this phenomenon is between 0.1% and 0.9%.
With institutional review board approval, the authors reviewed continuous quality improvement data from 3 yr (2002-2004) at the locations where the physician group provided anesthesia. Board-certified anesthesiologists supervising certified registered nurse anesthetists in the anesthesia care team model of practice delivered all anesthetics. Brain function monitors were not used in the operating room setting. Patients were interviewed twice during a 48-h postoperative period and, as part of that process, underwent a modified Brice interview to determine intraoperative awareness. All cases that met the criteria for awareness were examined by the continuous quality improvement committee to modify anesthetic practice and were included in this study.
Data from 211,842 patients undergoing anesthesia were considered. Of these, the continuous quality improvement process followed up 177,468 (83.1%). Cases were not included in the study if the patient was younger than 18 yr, did not have a general anesthetic, or had a terminal event during the hospital course. By these criteria, a total of 87,361 patients followed by the continuous quality improvement process were at risk for awareness. Six patients reported instances of recall.
The incidence of intraoperative awareness in this large sample of patients from a regional medical center undergoing general anesthesia was 0.0068%, or 1 per 14,560 patients, substantially less than that reported in the recent literature.
全身麻醉患者术中知晓是一种虽不常见但已被充分描述的不良结局。该现象的报告发生率在0.1%至0.9%之间。
经机构审查委员会批准,作者回顾了医师团队提供麻醉服务的机构在3年(2002 - 2004年)期间的持续质量改进数据。在麻醉护理团队实践模式下,由获得委员会认证的麻醉医师监督注册护士麻醉师实施所有麻醉。手术室未使用脑功能监测仪。患者在术后48小时内接受两次访谈,并在此过程中接受改良的布赖斯访谈以确定术中知晓情况。所有符合知晓标准的病例均由持续质量改进委员会进行审查以改进麻醉实践,并纳入本研究。
共考虑了211,842例接受麻醉的患者的数据。其中,持续质量改进流程对177,468例(83.1%)进行了随访。如果患者年龄小于18岁、未接受全身麻醉或在住院期间发生终末事件,则该病例不纳入研究。按照这些标准,持续质量改进流程随访的总共87,361例患者存在术中知晓风险。6例患者报告有回忆事件。
在这个来自地区医疗中心的接受全身麻醉的大量患者样本中,术中知晓的发生率为0.0068%,即每14,560例患者中有1例,显著低于近期文献报道的发生率。