Savelkoul Eileen M, Zebrowski Patricia M, Feldstein Stanley, Cole-Harding Shirley
Department of Communication Disorders and Special Education, Minot State University, Memorial 104J, 500 University Avenue West Minot, ND 58707, United States.
J Fluency Disord. 2007;32(1):1-32. doi: 10.1016/j.jfludis.2006.12.001. Epub 2007 Jan 30.
Coordinated interpersonal timing (CIT) is a measure of "conversational congruence," or "attunement," and refers to the degree to which the temporal aspects of the vocal behaviors of co-conversationalists are correlated over the course of a conversation [Jasnow, M., & Feldstein, S. (1986). Adult-like temporal characteristics of mother-infant vocal interaction. Child Development, 57, 754-761]. In the present study, CIT was examined in a group of children who stutter (CWS), and a matched group of nonstuttering children (CWDNS; children who do not stutter), during conversations with either their mother or father recorded in two separate sessions (i.e., mother-child, father-child). Separate audio signals for both the child and parent (mother or father) were analyzed using AVTA software, which allowed for the quantification of sound and silence patterns in simultaneous speech. Squared cross-correlations (i.e., coefficients of CIT) for the durations of five vocal behavior states were obtained for each subject, through time series regression analysis using lag procedures. Vocal state behaviors within conversational turns included: vocalization, pauses, turn switching pauses, and interruptive and noninterruptive simultaneous speech. Results indicated that CWS and their parents showed mutual influence (i.e., CIT in both directions, child to parent and parent to child, or bi-directional influence) for more vocal state behaviors than did CWDNS and their parents. In addition, the CWS exhibited CIT with their parents for the durations of more vocal state behaviors than did the CWDNS (i.e., unidirectional influence). Findings suggest that children who stutter may be more easily influenced by the subtle timing aspects of conversation. Taken further, some of these children may perceive conversations with their parents as either challenging or difficult because of an element of unpredictability brought into conversations by the production of stuttering, the social skills of the child, and the nature of the parent-child relationship. Consequently, these children may be engaging in more pervasive coordination of the temporal characteristics of their speech to those of their conversational partner, as a mechanism by which to more effectively manage verbal interaction.
After reading this paper, the learner will be able to: (1) describe the phenomenon of coordinated interpersonal timing (CIT); (2) summarize research findings in CIT as they apply to the verbal interactions of children and their parents; (3) summarize research findings in parent-stuttering child interaction, especially those related to the temporal aspects of both parent and child conversational speech, and (4) discuss the applicability of the findings from the present study to the treatment of childhood stuttering.
协调人际计时(CIT)是一种“对话一致性”或“协调”的度量,指的是在对话过程中共同对话者的言语行为的时间方面的相关程度[贾斯诺,M.,&费尔德斯坦,S.(1986年)。母婴言语互动中类似成人的时间特征。《儿童发展》,57,754 - 761]。在本研究中,对一组口吃儿童(CWS)和一组匹配的非口吃儿童(CWDNS;不口吃的儿童)在与母亲或父亲的对话中进行了CIT检查,对话记录在两个单独的时段(即母子、父子)。使用AVTA软件对儿童和父母(母亲或父亲)的单独音频信号进行分析,该软件允许对同步言语中的声音和沉默模式进行量化。通过使用滞后程序的时间序列回归分析,为每个受试者获得了五种言语行为状态持续时间的平方交叉相关性(即CIT系数)。对话轮次中的言语状态行为包括:发声、停顿、轮次转换停顿以及打断性和非打断性同步言语。结果表明,与CWDNS及其父母相比,CWS及其父母在更多的言语状态行为上表现出相互影响(即双向影响,从儿童到父母以及从父母到儿童)。此外,与CWDNS相比,CWS在更多言语状态行为的持续时间上与父母表现出CIT(即单向影响)。研究结果表明,口吃儿童可能更容易受到对话中微妙的时间方面的影响。进一步而言,由于口吃产生、儿童的社交技能以及亲子关系的性质给对话带来的不可预测性因素,这些儿童中的一些可能会将与父母的对话视为具有挑战性或困难的。因此,这些儿童可能会更广泛地将其言语的时间特征与对话伙伴的时间特征进行协调,作为一种更有效地管理言语互动的机制。
阅读本文后,学习者将能够:(1)描述协调人际计时(CIT)现象;(2)总结CIT在儿童及其父母言语互动中的研究结果;(3)总结口吃儿童与父母互动中的研究结果,特别是与父母和儿童对话言语的时间方面相关的结果;以及(4)讨论本研究结果在儿童口吃治疗中的适用性。