McNeil Shelly A, Noya Francisco, Dionne Marc, Predy Gerald, Meekison William, Ojah Cecil, Ferro Santiago, Mills Elaine L, Langley Joanne M, Halperin Scott A
Clinical Trials Research Center, IWK Health Centre and QEII Health Sciences Centre, Dalhousie University, 5850/5980 University Avenue, Halifax, NS B3K 6R8, Canada.
Vaccine. 2007 Apr 30;25(17):3464-74. doi: 10.1016/j.vaccine.2006.12.047. Epub 2007 Jan 9.
The annual contact for influenza vaccination provides an opportunity to ensure that adults have received other recommended vaccines such as Tdap. Healthy 19-64 year-olds were randomized to receive concomitant administration of Tdap and influenza vaccines or influenza vaccine followed (in 4-6 weeks by) Tdap. 720 participants were enrolled. No clinically relevant between-group differences were observed in the rates or severities of erythema, swelling, or pain at the Tdap injection site. Injection-site pain was the most commonly reported adverse event (66.6% concomitant administration group versus 60.8% sequential administration group); most pain was graded as mild and resolved by day 3. Seroprotection and seroresponse rates for all influenza strains were comparable between the two groups. For diphtheria and tetanus, seroprotection rates and post-vaccination GMTs were non-inferior in the concomitant administration group compared to the sequential administration group. A trend for lower antibody responses to pertussis antigens PT, FHA, and FIM was observed after concomitant administration and, for PRN, this difference failed the non-inferiority criteria. While there is a small diminution in antibody response to tetanus and pertussis antigens, concomitant administration of Tdap and influenza vaccine was well tolerated and immunogenic and may offer practical advantages including convenience, compliance, and cost-savings.
每年接种流感疫苗时都有机会确保成年人接种了其他推荐疫苗,如破伤风类毒素、白喉和无细胞百日咳联合疫苗(Tdap)。健康的19至64岁成年人被随机分组,分别接受Tdap和流感疫苗同时接种,或先接种流感疫苗,4至6周后再接种Tdap。共招募了720名参与者。在Tdap注射部位的红斑、肿胀或疼痛发生率及严重程度方面,未观察到组间存在临床相关差异。注射部位疼痛是最常报告的不良事件(同时接种组为66.6%,序贯接种组为60.8%);大多数疼痛为轻度,在第3天缓解。两组所有流感毒株的血清保护率和血清反应率相当。对于白喉和破伤风,同时接种组的血清保护率和接种后几何平均滴度(GMT)与序贯接种组相比不劣。同时接种后,观察到对百日咳抗原PT、FHA和FIM的抗体反应有降低趋势,对于PRN,这种差异未达到非劣效标准。虽然对破伤风和百日咳抗原的抗体反应略有降低,但Tdap和流感疫苗同时接种耐受性良好且具有免疫原性,可能具有包括便利性、依从性和成本节约等实际优势。