Buccoliero A M, Castiglione F, Gheri C F, Garbini F, Fambrini M, Bargelli G, Pappalardo S, Scarselli G, Marchionni M, Taddei G L
Department of Human Pathology and Oncology, University of Florence, viale G.B Morgagni 85, 50134 Florence, Italy.
Int J Gynecol Cancer. 2007 Jan-Feb;17(1):182-7. doi: 10.1111/j.1525-1438.2006.00757.x.
The incidence of endometrial adenocarcinoma in asymptomatic women is low. Nevertheless, some of these women might require endometrial surveillance. In this study, we evaluated the accuracy of liquid-based endometrial cytology compared to biopsy in asymptomatic postmenopausal women. Three hundred twenty women scheduled for hysteroscopy were enrolled for this study. After hysteroscopy, patients were submitted to endometrial cytology and to biopsy. Two hundred ninety-three (92%) women had sonographically thickened endometrium (>5 mm), 53 (17%) were on tamoxifen, and 16 (5%) were on hormonal substitutive treatment. The evaluation of the biopsies determined that six (2%) women had adenocarcinoma, one (<1%) had adenomatous atypical hyperplasia, and eight (3%) had simple nonatypical hyperplasia. Endometrial cytology evidenced 5 (2%) neoplastic cases, 2 (<1%) hyperplastic with atypia cases, and 25 (8%) hyperplastic without atypia cases. Two hundred twenty-two biopsies (69%) and 17 (5%) cytologies were inadequate. One adenocarcinoma and one simple nonatypical hyperplasia were underrated by cytology resulting, respectively, as atypical hyperplasia and as negative. Four cases were false positive (simple nonatypical hyperplasias on cytology, negative on biopsy). The sensitivity and specificity were estimated, respectively, at 94% and 95%; the positive and negative predictive value were estimated, respectively, at 80% and 99%. Endometrial cytology provided sufficient material more often than biopsy (P < 0.01). We suggest to introduce liquid-based endometrial cytology in the management of some subpopulations of asymptomatic postmenopausal women. Particularly, the combination of liquid-based endometrial cytology and transvaginal sonography may improve their diagnostic accuracy and reduce unnecessary more invasive and expensive procedures.
无症状女性子宫内膜腺癌的发病率较低。然而,其中一些女性可能需要进行子宫内膜监测。在本研究中,我们评估了无症状绝经后女性中液基子宫内膜细胞学检查与活检相比的准确性。320名计划进行宫腔镜检查的女性纳入本研究。宫腔镜检查后,患者接受子宫内膜细胞学检查和活检。293名(92%)女性子宫内膜超声增厚(>5mm),53名(17%)正在服用他莫昔芬,16名(5%)正在接受激素替代治疗。活检评估确定6名(2%)女性患有腺癌,1名(<1%)患有腺瘤性非典型增生,8名(3%)患有单纯非典型增生。子宫内膜细胞学检查发现5例(2%)肿瘤病例,2例(<1%)非典型增生病例,25例(8%)无异常增生病例。222例活检(69%)和17例(5%)细胞学检查结果不充分。1例腺癌和1例单纯非典型增生被细胞学检查低估,分别诊断为非典型增生和阴性。4例为假阳性(细胞学检查为单纯非典型增生,活检为阴性)。敏感性和特异性分别估计为94%和95%;阳性和阴性预测值分别估计为80%和99%。子宫内膜细胞学检查比活检更常能提供足够的样本(P<0.01)。我们建议在一些无症状绝经后女性亚群的管理中引入液基子宫内膜细胞学检查。特别是,液基子宫内膜细胞学检查和经阴道超声检查相结合可能会提高其诊断准确性,并减少不必要的更具侵入性和昂贵的检查。