Nishiura Hiroshi, Eichner Martin
Department of Medical Biometry, University of Tübingen, Tübingen, Germany.
Int J Hyg Environ Health. 2008 Mar;211(1-2):219-26. doi: 10.1016/j.ijheh.2007.01.029. Epub 2007 Feb 23.
Six historical studies were investigated to clarify the obtainable information on postexposure vaccination against smallpox. Using the distribution of incubation period, the frequency of cases by time from exposure to vaccination was obtained. More than half of all failures happened within 7d after exposure in all six records investigated. Based on two studies (n=36 and 28), the probability of escaping severe smallpox was further analyzed using logistic regression, showing an inverse association between severe smallpox and time from vaccination to onset (p<0.01 and p=0.04, respectively). Whereas the relationship between the probability of developing severe disease and the time from vaccination to onset could be analyzed with the available information, our findings indicate that previous epidemiologic records showing cases alone, rather than also showing individuals probably protected, are not useful for clarifying the effectiveness of postexposure vaccination by time after exposure.
为了阐明暴露后接种天花疫苗可获得的信息,对六项历史研究进行了调查。利用潜伏期分布,得出了从接触到接种疫苗的不同时间点的病例发生频率。在所调查的所有六项记录中,超过一半的接种失败发生在接触后的7天内。基于两项研究(n分别为36和28),使用逻辑回归进一步分析了逃脱严重天花的概率,结果显示严重天花与从接种疫苗到发病的时间呈负相关(p分别<0.01和p=0.04)。虽然利用现有信息可以分析发生严重疾病的概率与从接种疫苗到发病时间之间的关系,但我们的研究结果表明,以前仅显示病例而未显示可能受到保护个体的流行病学记录,对于阐明暴露后不同时间点接种疫苗的有效性并无帮助。