Rubin P J, Leyvraz P F, Aubaniac J M, Argenson J N, Estève P, de Roguin B
Lausanne Orthopaedic Hospital, Switzerland.
J Bone Joint Surg Br. 1992 Jan;74(1):28-32. doi: 10.1302/0301-620X.74B1.1732260.
Biological fixation of cementless femoral implants requires primary stability by optimal fit in the proximal femur. The anatomy of the bone must then be known precisely. We analysed in vitro the accuracy of bone measurements of 32 femurs and compared the dimensions obtained from radiographs and CT scans with the true anatomical dimensions. Standard radiographs gave only a rough approximation of femoral geometry (mean difference: 2.4 +/- 1.4 mm) insufficiently accurate to allow selection of the best fitting prosthesis from a range of sizes and altogether inadequate to design a custom-made prosthesis. CT scans give greater accuracy (mean difference: 0.8 +/- 0.7 mm) in our experimental conditions, but in clinical practice additional sources of error exist.
非骨水泥型股骨植入物的生物固定需要通过在股骨近端的最佳适配来实现初始稳定性。因此必须精确了解骨骼的解剖结构。我们在体外分析了32个股骨的骨测量准确性,并将从X线片和CT扫描获得的尺寸与真实解剖尺寸进行了比较。标准X线片只能大致估算股骨几何形状(平均差异:2.4±1.4毫米),其准确性不足以从一系列尺寸中选择最合适的假体,完全无法用于设计定制假体。在我们的实验条件下,CT扫描具有更高的准确性(平均差异:0.8±0.7毫米),但在临床实践中还存在其他误差来源。