Pories S E, Gamelli R L, Vacek P, Goodwin G, Shinozaki T, Harris F
Department of Surgery, University of Vermont College of Medicine, Burlington.
J Trauma. 1992 Jan;32(1):60-4. doi: 10.1097/00005373-199201000-00013.
The relationship between alcohol use and injury severity was investigated in trauma patients admitted to a tertiary referral hospital during a 23-month period. Admission blood alcohol levels (BALs) were obtained on 427 trauma patients, who were stratified into three groups: those with no measurable blood alcohol, those within the legal limit of 100 mg/dL, and those over the legal limit or intoxicated. The no-alcohol group had significantly lower injury severity than the other two groups (p less than 0.001). Even when the BAL was well within the legal limit, injuries suffered by those in the alcohol-positive groups were more severe than those in the no-alcohol group. Confirmatory evidence of the effect of alcohol on injury severity was reflected by a 2.3% mortality in alcohol-negative patients compared with a 13.3% death rate in alcohol-positive patients (p less than 0.0001). To assess the potentially confounding effect of alcohol on injury scoring accuracy, we examined the change in Glasgow Coma Scale (GCS) scores following admission. No significant differences were found when admission GCS values were compared with GCS determinations made 24 hours following admission by separate observers. To correct for any potential bias as a tertiary referral center, repeat analysis with exclusion of transferred patients was done with essentially no change in results. Our data revealed a highly significant relationship between alcohol use, degree of injury, and resource consumption.
在一家三级转诊医院收治的创伤患者中,对饮酒与损伤严重程度之间的关系进行了为期23个月的调查。对427例创伤患者进行了入院时血液酒精水平(BAL)检测,并将其分为三组:血液酒精不可测者、血液酒精水平在法定限度100mg/dL以内者、血液酒精水平超过法定限度或已醉酒者。无酒精组的损伤严重程度显著低于其他两组(p<0.001)。即使BAL完全在法定限度内,酒精阳性组患者所受损伤也比无酒精组患者更严重。酒精阴性患者死亡率为2.3%,而酒精阳性患者死亡率为13.3%,这一数据反映出酒精对损伤严重程度影响的确定性证据(p<0.0001)。为评估酒精对损伤评分准确性的潜在混杂效应,我们检查了入院后格拉斯哥昏迷量表(GCS)评分的变化。将入院时的GCS值与不同观察者在入院24小时后测得的GCS值进行比较,未发现显著差异。为校正作为三级转诊中心可能存在的任何偏倚,我们排除转诊患者后进行了重复分析,结果基本未变。我们的数据显示,饮酒、损伤程度和资源消耗之间存在高度显著的关系。